ROBERT K. TANENBAUM - Partial transcript of talk before the
Wecht Conference in Pittsburgh . From
CD Into Evidence - Truth, Lies and
Unresolved Mysteries in the Murder of JFK. 2003 40th Anniversary Conference
Cyril Wecht Institute of Forensic Pathology.
Transcribed excerpts from a presentation entitled: Limitations of the HSCA: Reflections of a Former Counsel
By William Kelly
“The conventional wisdom and that
of the Warren Commission (Warren Report,
p. 165) is that Tippit pulled his squad car over to talk to Oswald because
Tippit must have heard the description of the suspected killer of the
president, which was sent out over Dallas police radio at 12:45, 12:48 and
12:55 p.m., that he was a ‘white male, approximately thirty, slender build,
height five foot ten inches, weight 165 pounds,’ and Oswald’s description was
similar to the suspect.” - Vincent
Bugliosi “Reclaiming History” (W.W.
Norton, 2007 p. 78)
In the above quote, Mr. Bugliosi fails to include the entire
description of the suspect - he was also believed to be dangerous and armed
with a 30.30 rifle.
Former prosecutor and Congressional investigator Robert K.
Tanenbaun, in his address to the 40th Anniversary 2003 Conference at Cyril
Wecht Institute of Forensic Pathology, gave a talk on “Limitations of the House
Select Committee on Assassinations (HSCA): Reflections of a Former Counsel,” in
which he touched on the issue of how and why the Dallas Police so quickly
focused on Lee Harvey Oswald as a suspect, and explained its significance.
[ For a complete transcript of Tanenbaum’s 2003
address: ]
Robert K. Tanenbaum: …What
I am saying is that from the evidence we produced, there were substantial
questions about the assassination.…What I’d like to do very briefly is to
explain some of the reasons why, from a prosecutorial point of view, from what
our investigation revealed, there was, in my judgment, no case to convict Lee
Harvey Oswald of murdering the President….
When you hear from the
experts, and there are disputes among (the doctors)…they know the details about
the medical evidence, ballistics evidence, etc., but it is an overview that I
think one has to have to appreciate why there really is no case.
That is to say, how is it that the police, the cornerstone
of truth in every case, how is it that the police, out of the cosmos, focused
on the defendant? What led them to that? What was the trail? That’s the
credibility of the truth of your case. In our case, the Kennedy assassination,
the first question was - how was it that Oswald was stopped by Tippit during
the course and flow of the investigation that was happening so rapidly?
….How is it, in the
course of this investigation, that within an hour…, a couple miles away, a
police officer was able to stop Oswald, according to the Warren Commission, because he fit the description
that was sent out on the radio to the police at 12:48 PM ?
The assassination was
approximately 12:30 - at 12:48 a description of a suspect was sent out [-“‘white
male, approximately thirty, slender build, height five foot ten inches, weight
165 pounds.” Where did that description come from?]
And the answer the Warren Commission gives is that this fellow Brennan
was… looking up at the Depository window. And he allegedly see this person -
the shooter - Oswald the Warren Commission maintains, and was able to give a
description, a miraculous feat … because if he stood up in the window you would
only see a partial of his body [his knees] because the first few feet was
opaque. [the window was close to the floor]
Whoever the shooter
was that was in that window - in that Sniper’s Nest, he was crouched down
looking out that window which was raised about 12 inches. At best, if anybody
saw anybody in that window, they would have seen a partial of their face, at
best.
Brennan claims that he
gave this description up, but the question is who did he give it up to? One
naturally thinks he gave it to the Dallas Police, because they’re the ones who sent
the wire out at 12:48 that
justifies the Tippit stop.
In fact what happened was, he gave it to the Secret Service, to Forrest Sorrells, who came… back fromParkland Hospital , because all of the Secret Service people that were in Dallas were in the motorcade [or at the Trade
Mart] and they went to Parkland . Now again,…is this the kind of story that
someone would forget? Brennan reportedly said: “I don’t know. I may have given
it to a police officer or the Secret Service!”
In fact what happened was, he gave it to the Secret Service, to Forrest Sorrells, who came… back from
How many people have
met a Secret Service agent the day the President was assassinated and you gave
a description of someone who might have been the killer. Is that an individual
you would forget?
But Sorrells
corroborates what Brennan says! So we
know… a description of a suspect went out that wasn’t given from the person
that the Warren Commission alleges, and we are confronted with the problem of
who gave this description? That is, who gave the description who was at the
crime scene - as opposed to someone who gave the description sometime prior to
that.
At 12:48 p.m. ,
when the Dallas Police dispatcher gave out a description of a possible suspect
in the assassination, Oswald was outside the bus station about to get into a
cab, when a women appeared and asked the cab driver to call another cab for
her. Oswald offers her the cab - not the behavior of a murderer fleeing the
crime scene, but she declines and Oswald takes the cab across the Trinity River
viaduct to Oak Cliff and five blocks
beyond his rooming house on Beckley Avenue and walks back to it, apparently to
case it out to see if it was safe to return there.
Dallas Secret Service Chief Forrest Sorrells, who went to Parkland
Hospital with the motorcade, returned
immediately to Dealey Plaza
where he first inspected the back loading dock of the Texas School Book
Depository and was surprised that there were no police officers there. Sorrells
asked an employee on the loading dock if he saw anyone leave through the back
door, then walked around to the front door where he identified himself and
asked if there were any witnesses.
There were two, Brennan and Amos Eunis, both of whom
described the Sixth Floor Sniper as about 30 years old, with a white shirt -
Oswald wore a brown one. But Eunis said that the gunman did have a very
distinguishing bald spot on the top of his head, another specific detail that
eliminates Oswald as a suspect.
Both Brennan and Eunis said they would probably recognize
the Sixth Floor Sniper if they saw him again, but while they were both kept
standing at the curb, according to the official account, while they were
standing there Oswald exited the building by that front door, and neither man
recognized Oswald as the shooter as he waltzed right by them.
Because they couldn’t possibly have determined the height of
the sniper in the window, and didn’t give Sorrells their description until
after 12:48 , neither Brennan nor
Eunis could possibly be the source for the 12:48
description broadcast by the Dallas Police dispatcher.
Sorrells then met TSBD supervisor Roy Truly, who he asked to
draw up a list of employees so they could be questioned, and Sorrells requested
a stenographer to record their statements.
Shortly thereafter, Dallas Police Homicide Captain Will
Fritz arrived at the scene with Dallas Sheriff Bill Decker, and they were
called from the Sniper’s window by a Dallas Deputy Sheriff who found the spent
shells lying together in a straight line under the window sill. Fritz then went
up to the Sixth Floor and arrived there around the same time that they found
the rifle.
[The testimony of Roy S. Truly was taken at 2:30 p.m. , on May 14, 1964 , in the office of the U.S.
attorney, 301 Post Office
Building , Bryan
and Ervay Streets, Dallas , Tex. ,….]
…Mr. DULLES. You do not think he (the Sixth Floor Sniper) used
any of the elevators at any time to get from the sixth to the second
floor?
Mr. TRULY. You mean after the shooting? No, sir; he just could not, because those elevators, I saw myself, were both on the fifth floor, they were both even. And I tried to get one of them, and then when we ran up to the second floor - it would have been impossible for him to have come down either one of those elevators after the assassination. He had to use the stairway as his only way of getting down - since we did see the elevators in those positions.
Mr. TRULY. You mean after the shooting? No, sir; he just could not, because those elevators, I saw myself, were both on the fifth floor, they were both even. And I tried to get one of them, and then when we ran up to the second floor - it would have been impossible for him to have come down either one of those elevators after the assassination. He had to use the stairway as his only way of getting down - since we did see the elevators in those positions.
Mr. BALL. Now, you recall that in your testimony before the
Commission you told them that at some time after the shooting, you advised
Captain Fritz of the name of Lee Oswald and his address in Irving?
Mr. TRULY. Yes, I did.
Mr. BALL. And in order to place the time of it, was it before or after the rifle had been found on the sixth floor?
Mr. TRULY. I wouldn't know. I think it must have been around the (time the) rifle was found, because I was not on the sixth floor at that time, but when told - let's go back a few minutes - pardon me - I told Chief Lumpkin a good many minutes after we came down from the roof and he went ahead and gave some orders to two or three policemen surrounding him and then said, "Let's go up and tell Captain Fritz."
Mr. BALL. Now, what did you tell Chief Lumpkin when you came down from the roof of the building?
Mr. TRULY. When I noticed this boy was missing, I told Chief Lumpkin that "We have a man here that's missing." I said, "It my not mean anything, but he isn't here." I first called down to the other warehouse and had Mr. Akin pull the application of the boy so I could get - quickly get his address in Irving and his general description, so I could be more accurate than I would be.
Mr. BALL. Was he the only man missing?
Mr. TRULY. The only one I noticed at that time.
Mr. TRULY. Yes, I did.
Mr. BALL. And in order to place the time of it, was it before or after the rifle had been found on the sixth floor?
Mr. TRULY. I wouldn't know. I think it must have been around the (time the) rifle was found, because I was not on the sixth floor at that time, but when told - let's go back a few minutes - pardon me - I told Chief Lumpkin a good many minutes after we came down from the roof and he went ahead and gave some orders to two or three policemen surrounding him and then said, "Let's go up and tell Captain Fritz."
Mr. BALL. Now, what did you tell Chief Lumpkin when you came down from the roof of the building?
Mr. TRULY. When I noticed this boy was missing, I told Chief Lumpkin that "We have a man here that's missing." I said, "It my not mean anything, but he isn't here." I first called down to the other warehouse and had Mr. Akin pull the application of the boy so I could get - quickly get his address in Irving and his general description, so I could be more accurate than I would be.
Mr. BALL. Was he the only man missing?
Mr. TRULY. The only one I noticed at that time.
Mr. BALL. Did you make a check of your employees
afterwards?
Mr. TRULY. No, no; not complete. No, I just saw the group of the employees over there on the floor and I noticed this boy wasn't with them. With no thought in my mind except that I had seen him a short time before in the building, I noticed he wasn't there.
Mr. BALL. What do you mean "a short time before"?
Mr. TRULY. I would say 10 or 12 minutes.
Mr. BALL. You mean that's when you saw him in the lunchroom?
Mr. TRULY. In the lunchroom.
Mr. BALL. And you noticed he wasn't over there?
Mr. TRULY. Well, I asked Bill Shelley if he had seen him around and he said "No."
Mr. BALL. Now, you told Chief Lumpkin that there was a man missing?
Mr. TRULY. Yes; and he said, "Let's go tell Captain Fritz." Well, I didn't know where Captain Fritz was.
Mr. BALL. Now, did you tell Chief Lumpkin the man was missing before or after you called to the warehouse and got the name?
Mr. TRULY. No, I called the warehouse beforehand.
Mr. BALL. You didn't talk to any police officer before you called the warehouse and got the address?
Mr. TRULY. Not that I remember.
Mr. BALL. You did that on your own without instructions?
Mr. TRULY. That's right.
Mr. BALL. So, when you talked to Chief Lumpkin, you at that time had in your possession there the address of Lee Oswald in Irving?
Mr. TRULY. That's right, I had scribbled it down on a piece of map or something so I would remember it.
Mr. BALL. That is the address that he had put on his application form for employment?
Mr. TRULY. That's right.
Mr. BALL. And did you know of any other address
Mr. TRULY. I didn't know of any other address at all.
Mr. TRULY. No, no; not complete. No, I just saw the group of the employees over there on the floor and I noticed this boy wasn't with them. With no thought in my mind except that I had seen him a short time before in the building, I noticed he wasn't there.
Mr. BALL. What do you mean "a short time before"?
Mr. TRULY. I would say 10 or 12 minutes.
Mr. BALL. You mean that's when you saw him in the lunchroom?
Mr. TRULY. In the lunchroom.
Mr. BALL. And you noticed he wasn't over there?
Mr. TRULY. Well, I asked Bill Shelley if he had seen him around and he said "No."
Mr. BALL. Now, you told Chief Lumpkin that there was a man missing?
Mr. TRULY. Yes; and he said, "Let's go tell Captain Fritz." Well, I didn't know where Captain Fritz was.
Mr. BALL. Now, did you tell Chief Lumpkin the man was missing before or after you called to the warehouse and got the name?
Mr. TRULY. No, I called the warehouse beforehand.
Mr. BALL. You didn't talk to any police officer before you called the warehouse and got the address?
Mr. TRULY. Not that I remember.
Mr. BALL. You did that on your own without instructions?
Mr. TRULY. That's right.
Mr. BALL. So, when you talked to Chief Lumpkin, you at that time had in your possession there the address of Lee Oswald in Irving?
Mr. TRULY. That's right, I had scribbled it down on a piece of map or something so I would remember it.
Mr. BALL. That is the address that he had put on his application form for employment?
Mr. TRULY. That's right.
Mr. BALL. And did you know of any other address
Mr. TRULY. I didn't know of any other address at all.
Mr. BALL. In other words, you went with Chief Lumpkin to the
sixth floor, didn't you?
Mr. TRULY. Yes.
Mr. BALL. And what was your purpose of going there?
Mr. TRULY. My purpose in going there was to inform Captain Fritz that this boy was missing and give him his telephone number, and hisIrving address, at the suggestion of Chief
Lumpkin, who accompanied me.
Mr. BALL. Did you give Captain Fritz this name and address?
Mr. TRULY. Yes, I did.
Mr. TRULY. Yes.
Mr. BALL. And what was your purpose of going there?
Mr. TRULY. My purpose in going there was to inform Captain Fritz that this boy was missing and give him his telephone number, and his
Mr. BALL. Did you give Captain Fritz this name and address?
Mr. TRULY. Yes, I did.
Mr. TRULY. I told - well, when Chief Lumpkin and I went to the sixth floor, Captain Fritz was standing
in, the area where I later learned they had found the gun, and Chief Lumpkin
told Captain Fritz that Mr. Truly had something to tell him, which I would like
to tell him, so he stepped over 4 or 5 feet to where I was, away from the other
men -officers and reporters, I would say, that were on the floor, and I
repeated the words to Captain Fritz.
Mr. BALL. What did you tell him?
Mr. TRULY. I told him that we had a man missing - I told him what his name was and hisIrving address and he said, "All right,
thank you, Mr. Truly. We will get right on it," or words to that
effect, and so I left the sixth floor shortly. While I was up there, just as I
left Captain Fritz, a reporter walked over and said, "What about this
fellow Oswald?" And I said, "Where did you learn the name
'Oswald'?" Because I had talked rather low to Captain Fritz and I said,
"He's just an employee here," and I left.
Mr. BALL. What did you tell him?
Mr. TRULY. I told him that we had a man missing - I told him what his name was and his
Mr. BALL. Tell me about how many minutes you think it was
from the time you obtained the address of Lee Oswald until you told Captain
Fritz the name and address?
Mr. TRULY. I think it was immediately.
Mr. BALL. Immediately?
Mr. TRULY. Immediately, after I called to the warehouse and got his name and address inIrving , I turned around and walked over and told
Captain Fritz at that time.
Mr. BALL. Chief Lumpkin?
Mr. TRULY. Yes; Chief Lumpkin.
Mr. BALL. Yes; Chief Lumpkin.
Mr. TRULY. And I remember Chief Lumpkin talking to two or three officers and I stepped back and he went ahead and told them a few things - it could have been 2 or 3 or 4 minutes.
Mr. BALL. Not over that?
Mr. TRULY. I don't believe so, and then he came to me and said, "All right, Mr. Truly, let's go up and see Captain Fritz and tell him this."
Mr. TRULY. I think it was immediately.
Mr. BALL. Immediately?
Mr. TRULY. Immediately, after I called to the warehouse and got his name and address in
Mr. BALL. Chief Lumpkin?
Mr. TRULY. Yes; Chief Lumpkin.
Mr. BALL. Yes; Chief Lumpkin.
Mr. TRULY. And I remember Chief Lumpkin talking to two or three officers and I stepped back and he went ahead and told them a few things - it could have been 2 or 3 or 4 minutes.
Mr. BALL. Not over that?
Mr. TRULY. I don't believe so, and then he came to me and said, "All right, Mr. Truly, let's go up and see Captain Fritz and tell him this."
END TRANSCRIPT OF TESTIMONY
So TSBD Supervisor Roy Truly, despite having seen Oswald in
the Second Floor Lunchroom within a minute and a half after the last shot was
fired, for some reason, shortly thereafter, became suspicious after he didn’t see
Oswald with a group of employees, and on his own, called the employment office
in another nearby building and obtained from a “Mr. Aiken a description of
Oswald and the Irving address of Ruth Paine from his employment application,
which he wrote down.
Roy Truly then met Dallas Deputy Police Chief Lumpkin and
told him of his suspicions about Oswald, the missing employee who wasn’t the
only employee missing.
After Chief Lumpkin talked privately with two or three other
police officers he accompanied Truly to the Sixth Floor where Lumpkin
interrupted Fritz while they were inspecting the newly discovered rifle, and
Lumpkin told Fritz that Truly had something to tell him - “We have a man
missing,” - an employee name Lee Harvey Oswald - who lived on Fifth Street in
Irving, and he then gave Fritz Oswald’s description, Irving address and Mrs.
Paine’s phone number.
A reporter who apparently overheard Truly tell either
Limpkin or Fritz about Oswald, then asked Truly who “Oswald” was, and Truly
asked him, “Where did you get that name?” But before getting a response, Truly
answered the reporter’s question - Oswald was an employee, a missing one.
In the meantime, Dallas Sheriff Bill Decker had
countermanded Secret Service agent Forrest Sorrell’s request for a stenographer,
and had his deputies and officers escort witnesses to the Sheriff’s Office
across Houston Street ,
where Captain Fritz visited and talked briefly with Decker before returning to
the homicide office at Police HQ, a few blocks away. It would be interesting to
know what Fritz and Decker talked about at this brief meeting in Decker’s
office at a critical time in the unfolding investigation.
Back at his office, Captain Fritz gave Oswald’s name, Irving
address and Mrs. Paine’s phone number to one of his officers and ordered them
to go out to Irving and bring Oswald in for questioning, but Fritz was then
told that Oswald was right there - sitting a few feet away in his office,
having been arrested at the Texas Theater in Oak Cliff as a suspect in the murder
of Tippit.
At 3:46 p.m. (CST)
the first UPI wire service report to mention Oswald was sent out. It also
portrayed Oswald as JFK’s assassin and linked him to the FPCC, a report
that also quotes Dallas Police Captain Pat Gannaway.
“Dallas , Nov. 22
(UPI) - Police today seized Lee H. Oswald, identified as chairman of a ‘Fair
Play for Cuba Committee,’ as the prime suspect in the assassination of
President Kennedy…Police said Oswald, 24, was accused in the slaying of a
Dallas policeman shortly after the shooting of the President. Police Capt. Pat
Gannaway said the suspect was an employee in the building where a rifle was
found. Gannaway said the suspect had visited Russia
and was married to a Russian. This was not immediately confirmed.”
Both Dallas Deputy Police Chief George Lumpkin and Captain Pat
Gannaway deserve closer scrutiny because they not only played significant roles
in the identification of Oswald as a suspect, but because both also played
significant roles in the motorcade and the investigation of those who were considered
a threat to the president before the assassination.
Gannaway was assigned to the Special Services Unit, which
operated out of offices at the Dallas Fairgrounds, near the Civil Defense
Emergency bunker, and was personally responsible for assisting the Secret
Service in the investigation of those who had threatened the President or had
previously been involved in the attack on UN Ambassador Adli Stevenson.
Both Gannaway and Lumpkin were also officers in the Texas
Army Intelligence Reserve unit headed by Jack Chrichton, an acquaintance of
Oswald who arranged for Russian speakers to serve as translators for
investigators who interviewed Oswald’s Russian wife Marina.
In addition, it was Lumpkin who personally informed the Sixth Floor Sniper, whoever he was, that the motorcade was approaching, only a few minutes away.
Lumpkin was in the front seat of the Pilot Car, the first
car in the motorcade that drove about a half mile ahead of the rest of the
caravan and maintained radio contact with it, ostensibly to ensure that there
was no danger ahead.
After driving through the city of Dallas, Lumpkin’s pilot
car turned right on Houston and then pulled to the curb at the corner of
Houston and Elm to inform one of the three traffic patrolman standing there,
that the motorcade was approaching. Sixty feet above them, the Sixth Floor
Sniper crouched in the window, and could hear both Lumpkin say the motorcade
was approaching and the crackle of the car’s radio, giving the position of the president’s
car at the time, but according to those who observed the man in the window at
12:25 p.m., he was looking straight ahead, in the direction of the Grassy
Knoll.
The Pilot Car then pulled out and went in that direction and
under the Triple Underpass, its occupants apparently not noticing any signs of danger
as the motorcade approached Dealey Plaza .
Sitting in the back seat of Lumipkin’s Pilot car was Lt.
General George Whitmeyer, commander of all Army Reserve Units in East
Texas , including the 488th Military Intelligence Detachment, the
same unit headed by Crichton. More than half of the unit were Dallas
policeman, including both Gannaway and Lumpkin.
General Whitmeyer however, was not named on the officially
list of those who were approved to ride in the motorcade, and he was only
included at the last minute when Chief Lumpkin apparently invited him to go
along for the ride.
Gen. Whitmeyer was the military commander in overall charge
of the Army Reserve units that included Deputy Chief Lumpkin, who told the
Sixth Floor Sniper of the impending arrival of the Target Car, as well as
Captain Gannaway, who investigated potential suspects before the assassination
and gave Oswald’s name and background to the media.
Also under Whitmeyer’s command was Jack Crichton, who
provided the Russian translators who helped question Oswald’s wife Marina, and
Col. Frank M. Brandstetter, who managed the Havana Hilton when Castro took
over, employed Manuel Ray as hotel engineer, and was a personal friend of David
Atlee Phillips and Philippe de Vosjoli, the head of French Intelligence in
Cuba, Canada, Mexico and Haiti.
According to Brandstetter, when in Washington
D.C. he personally reported to Lieutenant
Colonel William B. Rose, chief of the Army Intelligence Reserve Branch Office
of the Assistant Chief of Staff, Intelligence (ACSI) at the Pentagon, who had
Brandy contact Col. Sam Kail, the U.S. Army military attaché at the US Embassy
in Havana .
According to the book, Our
Man In Acapulco: The Life and Times of Col. Frank M. Brandstetter by Rodney
P. Carlisle and Dominic J. Monetta (University of North Texas Press, 1999 p.
129) [published in Europe as Portrait of An Intelligence Officer]:
“Brandy served the 1959 session of his annual active duty at
the Pentagon in the Office of the Army Chief of Staff, Intelligence (ACSI),
working under…Colonel Bob Roth, in the Collection Division….This duty marked
his change from Mobilization Reserve to a career over the next eighteen years
of working directly for ACSI, sometimes on active duty, and at other times,
after retirement, on a strictly unpaid and voluntary basis. Over that time, the
officer to whom he reported at ACSI would change almost every two years. In the
ACSI office, continuity was provided by Mrs. Dorothe K. Matlack, a long-time
civil servant and chief of the Exploitation Section of the Assistant Chief of
Staff-Intelligence (ACSI-CX). Dorothe…personally knew Brandy and other officers
who worked to supply a continuing stream of good quality ‘humanit,’ or
human intelligence.”
What is most significant about Brandstetter’s post Havana
1959 associations with ACSI and Colonels William B. Rose, Robert Ross, Sam Kail
and Dorothe Matlack, is the fact that these are all the same people George de
Mohrenschildt dealt with in April 1963 when he left Dallas after suspecting
Oswald had taken a pot shot at Walker, and visited New York and Washington D.C.
before moving to Haiti.
In other words, Oswald’s best friend, who knew Oswald had a
rifle and suspected he took a shot at General Walker, was at the same time
dealing directly with the same Army Reserve intelligence officers who Col.
Brandy and the Dallas 488th Intel unit, which included Oswald’s associate Jack
Crichton, Deputy Chief Lumpkin and General Whitmeyer in the Pilot car, and
Capt. Gannaway all reported to and worked for. They were all part of the
relatively small and obscure US Army Reserve Intelligence network.
These are the same people - Roy Truly, Chief Lumpkin and
Capt. Gannaway - who first fingered Oswald as a suspect, who gave Capt. Fritz
Oswald’s Irving address and phone
number at Mrs. Paine’s home, and passed the information on to the media.
The question then arose - how did the Dallas police, the FBI
and official investigators learn of the address of Oswald’s rooming house on
Beckley Street in Oak Cliff, where he was known by the alias of Mr. Lee? Was
that address in the Oswald/Hidell military intelligence file?
Mrs. Paine knew the phone number, but not the location.
Oswald had the cab driver take him five blocks past the rooming house, and then
walked back, an intelligence tradecraft to ensure not only that the cab driver
didn’t know the exact location of his destination, but to enable Oswald to
visually check out the premises before he went there.
How did the investigators learn the address of Oswald’s
rooming house?
Shortly after Oswald’s name was publicized by the 3:46 p.m. UPI report, a Colonel Jones at the 112th
US Army Intelligence center at Fort Hood ,
near San Antonio , Texas
pulled Oswald’s military file and reviewed it quickly - first noticing that it
was cross index referenced to another file A. J. Hidell - indicating a possible
alias.
Together these files related to the Fair Play for Cuba
Committee - and New Orleans . Both
would have included records on Oswald’s military service in the USMC, news
clippings of Oswald’s defection, his USMC reserve status, news clippings of his
arrest in New Orleans , reference to
his radio debate and FPCC leaflets from the USS Wasp ONI security, which
included the 544 Camp Street
Address in New Orleans . It also
should have included the most recent reports of Oswald’s visit to Mexico
City and the CIA ’s
request to the ONI for a photo of Oswald.
With this information in his hands, Colonel Jones then
called the San Antonio FBI office and gave them the basic facts from the military’s
Oswald/Hidell files.
This could also be Gannaway’s source for the UPI 3:46 p.m. report, unless the 488th Army
Reserves Intelligence unit in Dallas
had the same files with even more up to date and relevant information, like the
address of Oswald’s rooming house.
Gen. Whitmeyer was in the middle of the back seat of the
Pilot Car, Dallas Police Chief Lumpkin was in the front seat (either driving or
riding in the passenger seat), Jack Crichton was arranging for the Marina ’s
translator, Col. Jones was rifling Oswald’s military files in San
Antonio , but where were Colonels Brandsetter, Rose,
Ross, Kael and Dorothe Matlock?
If they were in Dallas
they most certainly were at the Civil Defense Emergency Command Post at the
Dallas Fairgrounds, near by or possibly at the same location as the Dallas
Police Special Services bureau - which included the files on those who were
considered a threat to the President, especially those who had earlier attacked
UN Secretary Adli Stevenson.
As noted by Russ Baker (Family of Secrets, p. 121), “On
April 1, 1962, Dallas Civil Defense, with Crichton heading its intelligence
component, opened an elaborate underground command post under the patio of the
Dallas Health and Science Museum. Because it was intended for
‘continuity-of-government’ operations during an attack, it was fully equipped
with communications equipment. With this shelter in operation on November 22, 1963 , it was possible
for someone based there to communicate with police and other emergency
services. There is no indication that the Warren Commission or any other
investigative body or even JFK assassination researchers looked into this
facility or the police and Army Intelligence figures associated with it.”
If the assassination of the President was considered an
emergency, and the Dallas Civil Defense bunker at the Fairgrounds was
activated, it would have had the capability to listen simultaneously to all of
the emergency and security radio channels being used and to record them, and
coordinate any actions that had to be taken immediately in the course of the
crisis.
As also noted by Russ Baker, “In the hours following
Kennedy’s assassination, the Dallas Police Department passed along information
purportedly gleaned from Marina Oswald that suggested the possible ties between
her husband and the government of Cuba .
Though the information would turn out to be wrong, it was quickly passed to
Army Intelligence, and then passed along to the U.S. Strike Command at McDill
Air Force Base in Florida , the
unit that would have directed an attack on the island had someone ordered it in
those chaotic first hours after Kennedy’s death. That this sequence of events
took place is confirmed by the original Army cable from military intelligence
in Texas , declassified a decade
later. What is not clear is how close matters ever got to zero hour. A key
element in this tangled tale is the little-appreciated overlap between the
Dallas Police Department and Army Intelligence…”
Indeed, the name on the document - Don Stringfellow, was an
intelligence officer in the 488th and the Assistant Chief, Intelligence
Section, Dallas Police Department. He “notified 112th INTC
[Intelligence] Group, this Headquarters, that information obtained from Oswald
revealed he had defected to Cuba in 1959 and is a card-carrying member of
Communist Party,” thus attempting to parlay the
assassination, as others tried to do, into an invasion of Cuba.
Peter Dale Scott: “A more ominous provocation in 1963 was
that of Army Intelligence, one unit of which in Dallas
did not simply withhold information about Lee Harvey Oswald, but manufactured
false intelligence that seemed designed to provoke retaliation against Cuba .
I call such provocations phase-one stories, efforts to portray Oswald as a
Communist conspirator (as opposed to the later phase-two stories, also false,
portraying him as a disgruntled loner). A conspicuous example of such phase-one
stories is a cable from the Fourth Army Command in Texas ,
reporting a tip from a Dallas
policeman who was also in an Army Intelligence Reserve unit…The cable was not
an isolated aberration. It was supported by other false phase-one stories from Dallas
about Oswald’s alleged rifle, and specifically by concatenated false
translations of Marina Oswald’s testimony, to suggest that Oswald’s rifle in Dallas
was one he had owned in Russia .”
And as pointed out by Peter Dale Scott, “This cable was sent
on November 22 directly to the U.S. Strike Command at Fort
MacDill in Florida ,
the base poised for a possible retaliatory attack against Cuba .”
I also find it highly significant that we now know that
Watergate burglar Frank Sturgis, as well as student agitator and protest singer
Phil Ochs and other players like them were not FBI or CIA
agents or operatives, as their government files confirm, but were in fact military
intelligence agents reporting not to the CIA ,
but to the U.S. military, and run out of the Pentagon.
And in the case of those who first suspected Oswald’s
involvement in the assassination and gave his name and background to the
official investigators and the media - George deMohrenschildt, George Lumpkin, Pat
Gannaway, George Whitmeyer, Jack Chrichton, Frank Brandsetter and Don
Stringfellow - it is curious that they all reported to the small and obscure
Pentagon office with the innocuous title of US Army Intelligence Reserve Branch
Office, Assistant Chief of Staff for Intelligence (aka as ACSI), whose military
files on Oswald and Hidell, when requested by the HSCA, were reported routinely
destroyed.
No comments:
Post a Comment