Wednesday, May 29, 2019

Dallas COPA 2002 - The Case for A JFK Grand Jury

Dallas COPA 2002 - The Case for a JFK GRAND JURY


17 Years ago, Professor Phil Melanson, John Judge and myself devised a plan to petition for a special grand jury that would assemble all the evidence in the assassination of President Kennedy, call all living witnesses and determine if there was enough evidence to indict anyone for crimes related to the assassination.

I will make a transcript of this when I get a chance, but now, with a new reasonable democratic District Attorney in Dallas, he just might listen to us and convene a grand jury to do what we want - determine the truth and seek some semblance of justice.

COPA Conf in Dallas 2002 - 2 - YouTube

Tuesday, May 28, 2019

Ian Griggs - RIP

Ian Griggs – RIP

Image result for Ian Griggs JFKImage result for Ian Griggs JFK

Not as well known as the JFK assassination experts featured in the mainstream media, Ian Griggs is a living legend among independent JFK assassination researchers, even after his death.

From Hornchurch, Essex, England, Ian’s earliest memories were of the aerial dogfights over his home during the Battle of Britain in World War II, and his home was destroyed by a German V1 rocket.

 A British Army veteran who was deployed to Kenya and Kuwait, Ian served a 23 year career as a police officer, retiring in 1994. He was not your typical conspiracy theorist or JFK researcher. 

As the best researchers do, Ian took an aspect of the JFK assassination that lacked clarity and needed to be focused on, and chose to look closely at the Dallas Police Department, as he thought he knew something about such things.

In his book “No Case to Answer – A Retired English Detective’s Essays and Articles on the JFK Assassination 1993 – 2003” (JFK Lancer, 2005), Griggs outlines the chains of command within the Dallas PD, describing each bureau, their duties and responsibilities and who was detailed to each one.

It was Ian Griggs who called my attention to the Special Service Bureau – as this relatively small detachment played major roles in the assassination drama.

According to Griggs, “This was the first of the specialized departments. It operated under the command of Captain W. P. “Pat” Gannaway who was supported by six Lieutenants, 34 regular Detectives, 14 Patrolmen who were temporarily assigned to the Bureau and four female civilians (one stenographer and three clerk typists). The 14 ‘temporarily assigned’ men were what we in the UK would call Aides to CID or TDC’s (Temporary Detective Constables). More on them shortly.”

“Captain Gannaway (at that time known as ‘Mr. Narcotics’) had been in charge of the notorious 1957 undercover operation and raid that culminated in stripper Candy Barr being arrested for possession of half an ounce of marijuana. For this offense, she was sentenced to 15 years imprisonment, actually serving less than three years before being paroled.”

“Initially,” writes Griggs, “I had some difficulty in working out what the Special Services actually did….Indeed, eight of them testified before the Commission and three of them had their names as titles of Commission Exhibits. Careful study of the appropriate testimony, together with other DPD documents in my possession, finally enabled me to work out the purpose and responsibilities of the Special Service Bureau.”

“It was basically a covert surveillance and intelligence-gathering unit which, as well as the Criminal Intelligence Squad (CIS), included the Vice Squad and the Narcotics Squad, etc. It’s regular officers were plain-clothes detectives. Some were genuinely ‘on trial’ or undergoing training prior to being appointed full-time detectives. Others had been drafted from the uniform branch to undertake basic covert surveillance work in areas where their faces would not be known. A similar system exists in the UK and probably in other countries today.”

Quoting Lieutenant Jack Revill’s Warren Commission testimony Revill said: “I am currently in charge of the criminal intelligence section….Our primary responsibility is to investigate crimes of an organized nature, subversive activities, racial matters, labor racketeering, and to do anything that the chief might desire. We work for the chief of police. I report to a captain who is in charge of the bureau – Captain Gannaway.”

As Grigg’s points out, “For a very revealing account of the functions of the CIS, see Philip H. Melanson’s article ‘Dallas Mosaaic’ published in the Third Decade, vol. 1, no. 3, March 1985, pages 12-15." 


"Among other things, Dr. Melanson mentions that ‘the spooky little unit was physically removed from the rest of the DPD and was headquartered in a building on the state fairgrounds.” (Volume IV HSCA, 597)”

Now it’s understandable that the Special Services Bureau – that ran undercover informants, would not want them to report to DPD HQ at City Hall, but instead ran them from a remote base at the state fairgrounds, but that particular place is full of assassination related shenanigans – as I reflect on in my article -       JFKcountercoup: Shenanigans at the Dallas State Fairgrounds
.
Jack Ruby’s friends ran a tent show film there – “How Hollywood Makes Movies,” a failed enterprise that he got his Chicago friend Larry Meyers to invest $500 in, a show that when it folded, gave Ruby two of its employees – roustabout and former Army soldier Larry Crafard and dancer Joyce McDonald, who became a friend of Larry Meyers’ companion Jean Aase on the weekend of the assassination.

The state fairgrounds is also the home of the Science Museum, below which was the Civil Defense Emergency Communications bunker – supposedly nuclear bomb proof, that contained the most up to date Collins Radio equipment to maintain and control communications during a national emergency. That communications bunker was operated by oil man and US Army Reserve Colonel Jack Crichton, founder of the 488th Army Intelligence unit.

What Ian Griggs doesn’t mention and probably didn’t know is that more than half of the Special Services Bureau policemen were also officers in Crichton’s Army Reserve unit, and were very active on the day of the assassination.

For instance the pilot car in the motorcade – that drove about a mile ahead looking for signs of trouble – was driven by Deputy Chief of the Service Division George L. Lumpkin, a U.S. Army Reserve officer who arranged for the head of the U.S. Army Reserves in North Texas Col. Whitmeyer, to ride in the back seat, without the knowledge or approval of the Secret Service. 

When they got to Dealey Plaza Lumpkin pulled off to the side of the curb at Houston and Elm and informed one of the three traffic policeman assigned there – as well as the Sixth Floor sniper just above him, that the motorcade was only minutes away.

After allowing the motorcade to pass to get to Parkland Hospital, Lumpkin followed it, but then returned to the Texas School Book Depository (TSBD) where he met superintendent Roy Truly. Truly told him, that despite encountering Oswald in the second floor lunchroom within minutes of the shooting, and giving him a bye, Truly now considered Oswald suspiciously missing and informed Lumpkin. Truly had already called the main office and obtained Oswald’s Irving, Texas address of Mrs. Paine and gave it to Lumpkin. The two men then went up to the sixth floor of the TSBD, and after homicide Capt. Will Fritz was done inspecting the rifle, Lumpkin told Fritz about Oswald, giving him the Irving address.

Fritz then walked across the street to meet with Sheriff Bill Decker, a meeting for which there is no record, and then went back to his office at the DPD in City Hall. There he ordered some men to go out to Irving to get Oswald. “No need to do that,” he was told, “there he sits” in Fritz’s office, a suspect in the murder of Dallas patrolman J.D. Tippit.

Besides dissecting the Dallas Police Department for us, when he was in Texas Ian Griggs also interviewed a number of important witnesses – including Beverly Oliver – who he believes (and so do I), and Johnny Calvin Brewer – the shoe store salesman who noticed Oswald entered the Texas Theater without buying a ticket and pointed him out to police.

Although this fact has escaped most of those who have studied Brewer, Ian Griggs asked him the simple question – “Were you in the shop by yourself?”

And the answer was no!

JCB: “There were two other men in there. They were from IBM – they were in the neighborhood. I had known them ever since I came there.”

In a footnote Griggs says that “These men have never been identified.”

ILG: “Were they customers?”

JCB: “No, they weren’t customers. They’d just come in and kill time and lounge around.”

Brewer later says that after the arrest of Oswald, he returned to the shoe store and found that the two men from IBM had left and locked the door.

Now there was an official FBI investigation of the IBM office in Dallas, as a customer on the day of the assassination said that he had seen a film or video of the assassination on a television at the IBM office, something that was impossible as no film video had yet been released.

While video was in its infancy, IBM had developed early prototypes and they were in use at the time. And a US Army soldier assigned to an intelligence unit at Fort Hood said that his unit was taken to Dealey Plaza in plain unmarked trucks and videotaped the assassination, tapes that were immediately confiscated. 

JFKCountercoup2: Fort Hood Intelligence Unit at Dealey Plaza

Were those videotapes being viewed at the IBM office in Dallas when the customer accidentally saw them? And who were the two guys from IBM that were “lounging around” Brewer’s shoe store at the time he dropped a dime on Oswald?

Besides Griggs’ important work on the Dallas PD and his interviews with witnesses, Ian also demolishes the idea that the DPD lineups were of any value at all, though he spends more time on this issue than it probably deserves.

From what I understand Ian Griggs was working on another JFK assassination manuscript that he never got to finish due to his health, but I hope that some UK researchers will pick up on this and try to finish it or get it out as he left it.

In any case, Ian Griggs gave us many answers that we really appreciate, and he lives on in the important work he did.

[ BK NOTES: Please excuse the lapse of posts over the past few days as besides Ian Griggs, another good friend of mine suddenly passed and I had to attend his funeral. I will be posting regularly again from now on, so stay tuned. And if you can please support JFK research and my JFKCountercoup blogs – as big things are happening, and I will keep you posted. ]


Sunday, May 19, 2019

Actionable Legal Venues

Recommendations – Actionable Legal Venues - What Needs to be Done

There are many legal options, but they must take place in a very specific order to succeed.43)
And they are:

1)      A Congressional Briefing held in a briefing room in Congress. Any Congressman can request a briefing room reservation at any time, but we need a friendly Congressman to reserve such a room. I arranged for my Congressman William Hughes (D. 2 NJ) to arrange for such a room for a Press Conference announcing the formation of COPA –the Coalition on Political Assassination, and Rep. Cynthia McKinney (D. Ga.) arranged for a large hearing room to be utilized for a Congressional Briefing on the 911, so we have done this before. This Congressional Briefing in Congress must feature the top JFK assassination lawyers, researchers and investigators who could call attention to the most serious issues and convince Congress to hold public JFK Act oversight hearings. We must get the STAFF of the Congressional Oversight Committee to want to do this, as well as the chairman – Rep. Elijah Cummings (D. Md.) who should meet with a small select group of our key people. The Congressional Briefing is a preliminary step for a full House Oversight Committee hearing, in which each Congressman on the Committee gets a set time to question special expert witnesses and those responsible for the destroyed, missing and still withheld records. This Congressional Briefing must be held before Congress recesses for the summer.

2)      The Congress of the United States must, by law, eventually conduct meaningful oversight of the JFK Act of 1992 by holding public hearings that would be televised live on CSPAN focusing on illegally destroyed, missing and wrongfully withheld records on the assassination of President Kennedy. This hearing should be held in early September after Congress resumes.

3)      All of the remaining withheld records must be released in full as the law requires, but only Congress can make that happen.

4)      Congress should appoint a new – permanent Review Board that will oversee the JFK Act but also the recently enacted Cold Case Civil Rights Records Act, that requires a new Review Board.

5)      All of the living witnesses should be questioned and properly interviewed on the record, officially subpoenaed by the House Oversight Committee or its sub-committee on NARA if necessary, and the witnesses should be required to testify under oath.

6)      The Mainstream Media must be convinced to cover these briefings and hearings and detail how JFK assassination records were illegally destroyed, illegally went missing, and are still being wrongfully withheld, which should spark the justice department to take action.

7)      The Justice Department should appoint a special prosecutor and convene a DC Federal Grand Jury to investigate the crimes related to the assassination – including the destruction of records, the illegal theft of and the wrongfully withholding of specific records that we identify.

8)      CAPA attorney Bill Simpich has proposed convincing a Texas Municipal Judge convene a Court of Inquiry, a legal venue unique to Texas that could legally exonerate Lee Harvey Oswald for the assassination of President and require a new official inquiry. Any Municipal Judge in Texas could order such an Inquiry and the positive aspect of this is he is not required to conduct the inquiry, which another judge would be appointed to do. The Innocence Project, which has exonerated hundreds of falsely convicted victims, could cooperate in this endeavor. 

9)      The newly elected Democratic District Attorney of Dallas County John Creazot should be briefed privately on the cold case homicides in his jurisdiction that requires further investigation – including the assassination of President Kennedy and the murders of J.D. Tippit and Lee Harvey Oswald. He should respond by convening a local Special Dallas Grand Jury to conduct an investigation into these crimes to see if any new evidence and records and compel witnesses to testify. While this local Dallas Grand Jury would only require one assistant – District Attorney to conduct such a Grand Jury, most of the leg work, research, investigative leads and targeted records and witnesses could be provided by independent researchers who have been working on this case for decades.

10)  Both the DC based Federal Grand Jury and the Dallas based local County Grand Jury have the power to order an exhumation of the remains of the victims (JFK, John Connally, J.D. Tippit, Lee Harvey Oswald and Jack Ruby) for proper FORENSIC autopsies using the most up to date scientific equipment (X-Ray, MRI, photo, etc.) that will provide an enormous amount of new evidence that would be admissible in a court of law. A regular autopsy only determines the cause of death while a forensic autopsy creates evidence that can be introduced in a court of law.
For any of these legal proceedings to take place – they must begin with a Congressional Briefing and a Congressional Oversight Hearing on the JFK Act. All of the others then follow.

______________ 

Thursday, May 16, 2019

JFK's Secret Oval Office Tape Recordings

JFK's Secret Oval Office Tape Recordings

Image result for JFK secret white house tape recording system

JFK dictating his memoirs. The same system also tape recorded Oval Office, Cabinet Room and telephone conversation
Image result for 1963 dictabelt taping system

Model AT2C Dictaphone Belt Recorder similar to the one used by the Dallas Police and White House 

From the JFK Library in Boston 



Digital Identifier:
JFKPOF-140-014-p0001

Folder Title:
Clifton, C.V.
Date(s) of Materials:
13 November 1963

Folder Description:

This folder is part of an addition to the John F. Kennedy Presidential Papers, and consists of items that were recovered by the National Archives and Records Administration on behalf of the Kennedy Presidential Library from the estate of Robert L. White. 


So even though Robert White at first denied to the Assassination Records Review Board (ARRB) that he had any dictabelt tapes - he reluctantly admitted he did, and from this account - it is apparent that after he died the JFK Library did acquire some of the materials he obtained from Mrs. Lincoln. 

How many tapes did they obtain from White's estate? White told Christopher Fulton that some of the dictabelts broke while he was making cassette copies of them. How many were damaged by White and was the information on them obtained? 

And what became of the six cassette tapes that White made from the original dictabelts and given/sold to Christopher Fulton? 

From Mrs. Linconln's effects White also obtained hundreds, possibly thousands of documents, some of which are posted at the JFK Library web site. 

A sample document recovered from White is a memo from General Clifton to the President concerning the promotions of prominent military officers, which JFK did not always do on seniority. 

Clifton is a significant character in that he not only was the military advisor to the president but the longer, but still edited version of the Air Force One radio transmission tapes were found among his effects. 

Items in this folder consist of a memorandum to the President from Military Aide to the President General C.V. Clifton.Collection: Papers of John F. Kennedy. Presidential Papers. President's Office Files.


Here's a video with Secret Service Agent Robert I. Bouck, who was responsible for installing the tape recording system at the request of President Kennedy. On learning of the death of the President Bouck immediately went to the White House and uninstalled the system, which Mrs. Lincoln was apparently given custody of. 


I was unaware of this book, Listening In –  by Professor Ted Widmer of Brown University, which I haven't read yet, but he apparently went through the tapes at the JFK Library, made transcripts of some and published them in his book.  Here's an interview with him. 


Max Holland also wrote a book The Kennedy Assassination Tapes (2004) - but Holland only concentrates on the LBJ Tapes he obtained from the LBJ Library in Texas, and does not include many if any of the JFK Oval Office Tapes from before the assassination. 

Apparently there are three types of recordings - Oval Office conversations, Telephone conversations and dictated memos that President Kennedy made for his own use - as he expected to write an autobiography of his presidential years. 


The records of the Kennedy administration, including 248 hours of meeting tapes and 12 hours of telephone dictabelts, were moved to the National Archives in Washington and later transferred to the Federal Records Center in Waltham, Massachusetts. Finally, in 1976, the tapes were legally deeded to the Kennedy Library and the National Archives. Many of the tapes, most significantly more than 20 hours of recordings from the ExComm (the Executive Committee of the National Security Council) meetings during the 1962 Cuban missile crisis, were gradually declassified over the next two decades.

JFK Library Forum on Secret Tapes

Oval Office Recods Kept by Evelyn Licnoln

Sample recording of Nov. 1963

Description:
Sound recording of President John F. Kennedy dictating a memoir entry in November 1963. He talks about the coup in Saigon, South Vietnam, and the assassinations of Ngo Dinh Diem and Ngo Dinh Nhu, about the Soviet Union's stand on autobahn access, about American oil contracts in Latin-American countries, and about a statement by West German Chancellor Konrad Adenauer concerning the Berlin Wall. President Kennedy also speaks with his son John F. Kennedy, Jr.

The recording ends abruptly.
“Monday Nov. 4, 1963. Over the weekend the coup in Siagon took place…..conversation that divided the government here and in Saigon. Opposed to the coup were –  In favor of a coup were State –  I feel we must bear …”

Digital Identifier:
JFKPOF-TPH-51
Title:Telephone Recordings: Dictation Belt 51
Description: There is no sound recording or transcript for this item. The Dictation Belt is completely blank.
Physical Description:1 dictation belt (0 minutes)

Series 13.2.2. Telephone Recordings [Addition].
Extent: 24 Dictabelts containing approximately four hours of conversations, or at least 50 separate conversations or fragments of conversations.
Arrangement: Arranged by Dictabelt number.
The following Telephone Recordings, which were originally part of the Presidential Recordings Collection, were segregated out prior to the donation of the collection to the Kennedy Library. On March 9, 1998, these recordings were received by the Library and subsequently added to the collection. Dates are derived from documentary evidence within the collections of the Kennedy Library and cover notes received with the dictabelts. All of these Telephone Recordings are processed and available for research use. There are no transcripts for any of these recordings.
Series 13.1. Presidential Recordings: Meetings.
Extent: 127 tapes, 124 of which contain meetings or conversa¬tions. The 124 tapes with meetings and conversations have a combined running time of approximately 248 hours.
Arrangement: Arranged by original tape number.
The substance recorded on the tapes is predominantly meetings with the president in either the Oval Office or in the Cabinet Room. None of the recordings appear to be located elsewhere. Some tapes have only one meeting, others have several, and in still other cases a meeting is continued from one tape to another. Sometimes the recording does not begin until the meeting is already under way, and sometimes it ends before the end of the meeting. At other times the recording was left on and recording continued long after the end of a meeting. On some occasions the recording was apparently turned on accidentally by custodial personnel cleaning the oval office or Cabinet Room. Because of the fragmentary nature of some of the truncated meetings and conversations, and because of the tendency of some meetings and conversations to merge into one another as they do in the normal course of a business day, it is not possible to give a precise count of the number of separate e meetings and conversations. However, a rough count indicates the number to be well over 300. 

Some meetings and conversations are only a few minutes in length, but many last for periods from one-half hour to two hours. All the recordings were taken from audiotapes. Each tape contained at least one and sometimes several meetings and fragments of meetings or conversations. 

Each tape is identified by its number, by the date found on the reel box or corresponding rough transcript, and by the principal topics of conversation or meeting. Tape numbers interpolated by the Kennedy Library for previously unnumbered tapes inserted into the list in chronological sequence appear in parentheses. Dating, for the most part, is verifiable by matching the event recorded to the daily appointments calendar of the president, and dates for these events are given with a much greater degree of confidence than in the case of the telephone conversation items. 

While the recording was deliberate in the sense that it required manual operation to start and stop the recording, there does not seem to be a systematic pattern to its use. It was not, based on the material recorded, used with daily regularity, although it was used often. Nor was it used on some occasions when one might have expected it, such as the October 18, 1962 meeting with Andrei Gromyko.
The earliest established date for material recorded is 30 July 1962, and the latest is 8 November 1963. About 60 percent of the material recorded covers topics in international and foreign policy, including international economics. Another 15 percent deals with national defense. Further small amounts of material on intelligence, space, and atomic energy bring to at least 75 percent the proportion subject to national security protection. The remaining 25 percent of the substance is civil rights, the domestic economy, labor disputes, and other similar matters. There is some, but very little in the way of partisan politics apart from the context of the substantive matters of administration policy and legislation.

Top of Form
Digital Identifier:
JFKPOF-139a-009-p0001
Folder Title:
Roll 28: Palm Beach, Florida logs and traffic, November 1963: 16-18
Date(s) of Materials:
November 1963: 16-18
Folder Description:
This file contains materials collected by the office of President John F. Kennedy’s secretary, Evelyn Lincoln, concerning the incoming and outgoing messages that passed through the White House communications center. Topics include the activities of the Inter-American Press Association and President Kennedy’s meeting with Brazilian President João Goulart.

Collection:
Papers of John F. Kennedy. Presidential Papers. President's Office Files.

The last tape that I can find is dated November 8, 1963  

This sample tape is from November 4, 1963 and concerns the Coup in South Vietnam. 

Sample recording of Nov. 1963
Description:
Sound recording of President John F. Kennedy dictating a memoir entry in November 1963. He talks about the coup in Saigon, South Vietnam, and the assassinations of Ngo Dinh Diem and Ngo Dinh Nhu, about the Soviet Union's stand on autobahn access, about American oil contracts in Latin-American countries, and about a statement by West German Chancellor Konrad Adenauer concerning the Berlin Wall. President Kennedy also speaks with his son John F. Kennedy, Jr.

The recording ends abruptly.

Then there is this recording that contains nothing - was it erased? 

Digital Identifier:
JFKPOF-TPH-51
Title:
Telephone Recordings: Dictation Belt 51
Description:
There is no sound recording or transcript for this item. The Dictation Belt is completely blank.
Physical Description:
1 dictation belt (0 minutes)

Series 13.2.2. Telephone Recordings [Addition].
Extent: 24 Dictabelts containing approximately four hours of conversations, or at least 50 separate conversations or fragments of conversations.
Arrangement: Arranged by Dictabelt number.
The following Telephone Recordings, which were originally part of the Presidential Recordings Collection, were segregated out prior to the donation of the collection to the Kennedy Library. On March 9, 1998, these recordings were received by the Library and subsequently added to the collection. Dates are derived from documentary evidence within the collections of the Kennedy Library and cover notes received with the dictabelts. All of these Telephone Recordings are processed and available for research use. There are no transcripts for any of these recordings.
Series 13.1. Presidential Recordings: Meetings.
Extent: 127 tapes, 124 of which contain meetings or conversa¬tions. The 124 tapes with meetings and conversations have a combined running time of approximately 248 hours.
Arrangement: Arranged by original tape number.
The substance recorded on the tapes is predominantly meetings with the president in either the Oval Office or in the Cabinet Room. None of the recordings appear to be located elsewhere. Some tapes have only one meeting, others have several, and in still other cases a meeting is continued from one tape to another. Sometimes the recording does not begin until the meeting is already under way, and sometimes it ends before the end of the meeting. At other times the recording was left on and recording continued long after the end of a meeting. On some occasions the recording was apparently turned on accidentally by custodial personnel cleaning the oval office or Cabinet Room. Because of the fragmentary nature of some of the truncated meetings and conversations, and because of the tendency of some meetings and conversations to merge into one another as they do in the normal course of a business day, it is not possible to give a precise count of the number of separate e meetings and conversations. However, a rough count indicates the number to be well over 300. Some meetings and conversations are only a few minutes in length, but many last for periods from one-half hour to two hours. All the recordings were taken from audiotapes. Each tape contained at least one and sometimes several meetings and fragments of meetings or conversations. Each tape is identified by its number, by the date found on the reel box or corresponding rough transcript, and by the principal topics of conversation or meeting. Tape numbers interpolated by the Kennedy Library for previously unnumbered tapes inserted into the list in chronological sequence appear in parentheses. Dating, for the most part, is verifiable by matching the event recorded to the daily appointments calendar of the president, and dates for these events are given with a much greater degree of confidence than in the case of the telephone conversation items. While the recording was deliberate in the sense that it required manual operation to start and stop the recording, there does not seem to be a systematic pattern to its use. It was not, based on the material recorded, used with daily regularity, although it was used often. Nor was it used on some occasions when one might have expected it, such as the October 18, 1962 meeting with Andrei Gromyko. The earliest established date for material recorded is 30 July 1962, and the latest is 8 November 1963. About 60 percent of the material recorded covers topics in international and foreign policy, including international economics. Another 15 percent deals with national defense. Further small amounts of material on intelligence, space, and atomic energy bring to at least 75 percent the proportion subject to national security protection. The remaining 25 percent of the substance is civil rights, the domestic economy, labor disputes, and other similar matters. There is some, but very little in the way of partisan politics apart from the context of the substantive matters of administration policy and legislation.

If you can, please support JFKCountercoup: