Tuesday, January 8, 2013

"FBI Had SS Records Thought Destroyed" - Tunheim



                                        Judge John Tunheim addressing a COPA conference

   The Workings of the Assassinations Records Review Board
John R. Tunheim (Gave this talk after the ARRB dissolved) 

"...when the Secret Service destroyed a group of records that we were seeking, which they said were destroyed inadvertently—they were the threat assessment records before the November 1963 period, we found copies of those records in the FBI files." - John Tunheim 

                  Good afternoon, everyone. I’m going to stick to my time limits today. I want to leave time for your questions. That is one of the most important parts of these events.

                  Although I am a federal judge right now, four years in the 1990’s, for four years, I served as chairman of the federal agency that was charged with finding what were then still secret records from the Kennedy assassination and getting as many of them released as quickly as possible to the public.

                  The law that Congress passed, The President John F. Kennedy Records Collection Act of 1992, was a reaction not only to the movie by Oliver Stone which brought the issue to the fore, but also due to the years of dedicated work done by researchers who felt they were trying to research this important subject with one arm tied behind their back, because so many government records from the 1960’s were still classified. It doesn’t take much to classify a record. That is still a problem that exists in Washington today. You put “Top Secret” on a document and perhaps 30 or 40 years later it might get released.

                  The bill was passed in 1992 by Congress, President Bush was empowered to make the appointment; he did not make an appointment. He opposed the bill, thinking it was unconstitutional, and therefore he ignored the impact of the law and it fell to President Clinton to make the appointment.

                  I was nominated by President Clinton in September of 1993, and we were all confirmed, a five member board, consisting of myself, the one required lawyer on the board, and four academics, one of whom was a professional archivist, and three who were presidential historians. This Act put control of declassification of federal records, albeit in a single category, in the hands of an outside independent body for the first time. We were an independent agency within the executive branch which meant that we were handling executive branch records, which got around the constitutional issue.

                  We were independent and couldn’t be simply fired by the president. All government records on the Kennedy assassination were to carry a presumption of openness, and agencies were required to organize their files and present them to us, along with any argument as to why a particular record should remain sealed. When we made our decision about releasing a document, the agency could appeal our decision to the president. There was no part of this effort that was to go before the courts, the president being ultimately in control of executive branch records.

                  We were also to do our best to search for state, local, and private records to be part of the collection, and we were empowered to try to clear up, as best we could, some of the evidence. What we were not supposed to do, and we did not do, was to try to decide what happened. The whole goal of this effort was to find all of the records and release them to the extent possible.

                  We released just about everything that we got our hands on; then let the public decide: open the records to researchers, let them look through them, and let the public decide what happened.

                  We made several important decisions at the beginning. All of the documents were considered on a word-by-word basis, which means that no entire document was ever sealed or kept under wraps by our efforts. We occasionally would redact information—not very much. We did not redact any information that was central to the assassination story. We did redact names of certain intelligence agents who were still alive; we felt that their lives might be endangered if it was known that they were CIA agents. We used their pseudonyms instead. But for every piece of information we redacted, we set a release date. All of those release dates have now passed. The only records that have not been released are records that will be released in 2017. These non-released documents were not considered central to the assassination story, but they contain national security information.

                  The standard we applied was very interesting. We had to weigh interests.  We weighed interests such as public interests and interests like national security, intelligence gathering methods, personal privacy, and presidential security. But with the great interest in the Kennedy assassination records, we released just about everything. We found that just about everything satisfied that standard. We had a staff of about 30 people; we held hearings around the country. We defined expansively what an assassination record was. There are those who would argue that President Kennedy was killed, for example, because he was going to withdraw advisors from Vietnam. That’s a theory that some people expressed. We didn’t take a position on that, but we went and found all of President Kennedy’s administration’s records on Vietnam policies, and released them. That’s the way we did our work—not taking sides on any particular place, but just getting everything out.

                  We issued in the four years over 27,000 decisions.  There were an additional 33,000 decisions that were called “consent releases:, which is a fancy way of saying the agency wanted the information protected, but the agency knew we weren’t going to protect the information, so the agency just gave up. There were no successful agency appeals at the White House, President Clinton signaled early on that we were going to do this work and he wasn’t going to interfere with it.

                  The collection includes all the evidentiary material from the Warren Commission, and includes the voluminous collection of The House Committee on Assassinations. We have about 1.6 million pages of material from the Central Intelligence Agency that was shipped over and declassified and archived.

                  The total collection today is over 6 million pages. It is the largest single collection at the National Archives. It has an index at www.nara.gov . We had very interesting relationships with the federal agencies who were involved, and in the end we knew their files better than they did, because we were looking at their files and we were examining everything.

                  Now, one question that people ask is: “Weren’t there records that were destroyed over the years?” Well yes there were. I’m sure there were records that were destroyed before we got into the action, 30 years after the assassination. The voluminous collection maintained by James Angleton at the CIA was largely destroyed when he was fired from his job as Chief of Counterintelligence in 1975. The files of J. Edgar Hoover were burned upon his death. So there are records that disappeared.

                  But if a record was destroyed at the CIA, the State Department likely may have a copy of the record, or it may be at the FBI, or at the National Security Agency. There are copies of records galore throughout the federal government, so when the Secret Service destroyed a group of records that we were seeking, which they said were destroyed inadvertently—they were the threat assessment records before the November 1963 period, we found copies of those records in the FBI files.

                  The FBI, fortunately, kept all their records in a very organized fashion. The CIA, on the other hand had no clue where records were with their filing systems. They were off in warehouses, they were misfiled; we had a hard time finding records within the CIA.

                  Just to inform you of some of the efforts we made, we hunted for a lot of extra records, such as in New Orleans. Professor Fetzer mentioned the Garrison investigation and prosecution of Clay Shaw. We went to New Orleans to get as many records as we could. A cousin of one of Clay Shaw’s former partners came forward with the diary that Clay Shaw had written during the trial, which is now a pretty interesting part of the collection.

                  We held a public hearing in New Orleans, and the District Attorney said, “I will help you with whatever you want. All of our records are yours. Nothing’s been destroyed.” Watching that hearing at the time was an investigator that the District Attorney had fired. This man was fired shortly after the new District Attorney came on board. The investigator was fired because he refused to destroy the Grand Jury records that Garrison had used in the prosecution of Clay Shaw. About three or four days later, he showed up in Washington with all the Grand Jury records from the investigation by Jim Garrison on Clay Shaw. They were wonderful records, including testimony by Marina Oswald and others. The District Attorney fought us on that all the way to the Supreme Court, on the basis of whether our power or the states secrecy law trumped the other side. So that is an example of some of the fights we had.

                  Professor Fetzer discussed some of the changes Gerald Ford made in the Warren Commission narrative. This was a significant change even though he denied it was significant. We found that because the chief counsel of the Warren Commission had taken all of the edited early versions of the Warren Report home with him. His son came to us and said that they had been in his dad’s basement for years. He’s dead now, and the son didn’t know what to do with them and asked if we wanted them. Of course we wanted them. Of course we did. All 18 early versions of the Warren Report were included in our records. Gerald Ford’s was right there in plain sight, so we had to address that.

                  We tried to do our best with the photographic record. We were 30 years after the fact. We established there were probably between 80-100 photographs taken in the autopsy room in the Bethesda Naval facility. There are 15 of these photographs that exist today. They have passed through Kennedy’s physician, George Burkley’s hands, through Robert Kennedy’s hands, eventually back to the National Archives, where they are held through a deed of gift, where permission needs to be received from the Kennedy family to view them. Many photographs were destroyed.

                  That raises the question as to why the photographs were destroyed, and why other photographs were not destroyed.

                  We had these 15 original photographs from the 60’s that were fading. We had them digitalized. They’re very precise now; they will be preserved for history in this precise way. We brought in experts one day to look at them and look at the x-rays. They looked at everything we had. Now, some have argued that some of these photographs are fraudulent documents, but we took what we had. We brought in a group of experts, pathologists who had a great deal of experience, and we asked them to tell us what they thought. They spent a lot of time looking at these documents, and they came to a conclusion that the shot was a head shot that hit in the top of the back of the skull in what they called a trenching wound, meaning that it trenched along, breaking open the flap that is visible in the pictures. In their view, at least in the pictures we had, we collected everything that was available at this time; - they didn’t think that the bullet hit brain tissue, but the shock waves was enough to kill him instantly when the bullet hit.

                  The Zapruder film was something we spent time on. This film has an interesting history. It was taken the day of the assassination and made into the film. It was processed right away. Three first day copies were made. The government kept each of the first day copies; one of them went to the secret service. The original was sold almost immediately to the Time/Life Corporation. They had exclusive control over the images.

                  These are things that would not happen today. These things happened in 1963. Part of the original film had some damage to it while Time/Life held it. As a result, they became increasingly concerned about holding this important piece of evidence. They sold it back to Henry Zapruder, who was the son of Abraham Zapruder. Henry was a Washington lawyer who died several years ago. The film then went directly to the National Archives. Whatever you think of the Zapruder film, we had the film, and it should be maintained. We had it analyzed by experts at Kodak. They did not feel it had been altered, at least that particular copy that they had tested. And we took it, in the Constitutional sense, from the Zapruder family. So the original film is maintained under perfect conditions, at the National Archives, where it is stored. And it has been digitalized, which of course means it is much easier to see. So we did what we could with the Zapruder film. We had some issues dealing with the Zapruder family.  We tried to get them to donate the original film to the United States. We came close at times, but in the end, there was a lawsuit trying to establish the value of the film.

                  We spent a lot of time trying to get records out of the former Soviet Union. Oswald spent two and a half years there under very close supervision and observation by the KGB. There is a file about eight feet high in Minsk, which includes everything he said and did. It is in remarkable detail; the KGB did its job very well. They kept tabs on him at all times; they were very concerned about him. I’ve seen a lot of the files out of that series of documents, but we haven’t been able to get more than 400-500 pages of that file. We have a horrible relationship with the government of Belarus. It just keeps getting worse over time. In Soviet files in Moscow, there are also files that we haven’t got access to yet. The KGB did an investigation into the assassination. It is an important set of documents. For the future, will we get them?  I don’t know.

                  Things don’t seem to be going too well with Russia these days, so at some point in time, if they need something from us, if we are smart enough, we’ll ask them to share their archives on the assassination of President Kennedy with us. Maybe we’ll get something out of them then. So there is more work to be done, there are files in Mexico City that still haven’t seen the light of day; those files are important because Oswald spent some crucial time there. These are just some of the projects that should be pursued.

                It was a remarkable experience to work with all of these documents; we tried very hard to review everything that someone might have seen as relevant. This was a one time opportunity to open up classified documents and government files. There are upward of 100-150 researchers a day looking at these files. That was the whole idea behind this effort; it was to open it up and finally trust the people to review the records themselves and decide what happened, rather than have the government tell them what to do.

                  I want to recall, in closing, this was 1963—it was a very different world then. The Dallas police force was a relatively small town police force, and, in my opinion, a corrupt police force. They were corrupt in a small sort of way, in accordance with the standards of that era. A person like Jack Ruby could spend a weekend in the police station, probably carrying a gun the whole time, and not attract any attention. That is why Lee Harvey Oswald was paraded out twice for press conferences during the 44 hours he was held by the Dallas Police. But security standards were very different in that day and age.

                  The Secret Service, on the day of the assassination, the blackest day in the history of that organization, which dates back to within months of Lincoln’s assassination, their procedures and practices were completely changed because of that day in Dallas. A lot of the things we look at today looks like almost criminal negligence on their part and the part of the other agencies that were following Oswald at the time. But the fact of the matter is, it was standard practice in 1963.We didn’t protect our presidents very well. We had a remarkably lax set of standards at that time.

                  Just go forward another 30 years and look at Timothy McVey. Imagine when Timothy McVey was arrested in the Oklahoma City bombing in 1965. Did the authorities parade him out to two press conferences? Did they attempt to transfer him in an unsecured facility? Absolutely not. Those things never happen today. When you think back to 1963, and look at these investigations that were poorly done — they were poorly done, partly because they were done by the standard of the times. The Warren Commission reflected that as well.

                  I’ll quit now, so we’ll have time to talk.

[Note: The presentation by Judge Tunheim was not the COPA conference where the above photo was taken, but was recorded by Sean Windingland and along with many of the other presentations, placed on youTube. Using the recording preserved by Windingland on YouTube, John Delane Williams transcribed Judge Tunheim’s presentation. Tunheim, J.R., (Chair) and others (1998). Final report of the Assassination Records Review Board. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.]  

Blaine's Tampa Survey Report


                                                                                                                                                                  1-16-602.111

White House Detail                                Washington, D. C. 

December 4, 1963

FINAL SURVEY REPORT
Re: Visit of the President to Tampa, Florida, on November 18, 1963, where He Participated in Ceremonies for Strike Command, Florida Chamber of Commerce, and United Steel Workers.

Mr. James J. Rowley
Chief, U.S. Secret Service
Washington D.C. 

Sir:

INTRODUCTION

This survey was conducted by SAs Gerald S. Blaine and J. Frank Yeager, White House Detail, SAIC Rudolph E. McDavid, Jacksonville and RA Arnold E. Peppers Tampa, in and around Tampa, Florida, from November 11 through November 18, 1963.

It is estimated that approximately 20,000 people attended the speech at Al Lopez Stadium; 4,000 at Ft. Homer Hesterly Armory; and 2,000 at the International Inn.

ITINERARY

See Attachment #1 Revision:

2:30 p.m. The President arrived at Ft. Homer Hesterly Armory.

4:30 p.m. The President departed for Miami, Florida.

All other items remained the same.

ROUTES

See Attached #6

SECURITY

Motorcade Route

A parade motorcade with motorcycle escort was used on all movements in Tampa, with a pilot car used in advance of the motorcade. All intersections [page 2] along the route were controlled by uniform police officers and these men were reinforced by motorcycle escort intersection control. The sheriff’s offices secured the roofs of all major buildings in the downtown and suburban areas.

All underpasses were controlled by police and military units. The police department secured all rail traffic during the visit as the motorcade passed over rail arteries enroute.

Al Lopez Stadium

Members of the Tampa Police Sheriff’s offices, and Military Police secured the stadium, commencing at 8:00 p.m. on November 17, 1963. The playing field portion of the stadium was secured, except for 300 seats reserved for VIP’s. No one had access to the speaker’s stand. Members of the speaker’s stand were identified by name plates and a check list.

The field stands were secured until after landing of the helicopter, and they were filled. The route of departure from the stadium was secured by Military Police units from McDill Air Force Base.

Ft. Homer Hesterly Amory

This armory is a National Guard installation and members of the National Guard and Tampa Police were used to secure the grounds and interior of the armory.

The President entered through the rear of the armory, and the general public had access to the armory through the main entrance.

Speaker’s stand guests were identified by members of the Florida State Chamber of Commerce and an agent of this Service. Admission to the armory was by invitation for the seating on the main floor; seating in the balcony was open to the general public.

International Inn

The International Inn is a hotel located on West Shore Boulevard and Grand Central. The hotel was secured by members of a sheriff’s office and plain clothed detectives from Tampa, Florida. The ballroom used by the President was secured 24 hours prior to the arrival of the President, and was inspected by bomb squad of the Tampa, Florida, Police Department.

Admission to the International Inn was by invitation only.

Officer’s Club, McDill Air Force Base

The Officer’s Club at McDill Air Force Base was secured by members of the CSI and Military Police. RA Arnold Peppers conducted a back-ground check on all waiters used to serve at the luncheon.

[page 3]

POST ASSSIGNMENTS

See Attachment #2

INSTRUCTONS TO AGENTS

See Attachment #3

AUTOMOBILES

The President used a 1964 white Lincoln convertible at McDill Air Force Base, and the Secret Service used a black 1964 Lincoln hard-top for follow-up. The President’s automobile was driven by SA Greer, the follow-up was driven by SA Rybka.

On the downtown motorcade route, the presidential bubble-top Lincoln, driven by SA Greer, and the follow-up SS-678-X, driven by SA Kinney, were used.

The local Ford and Lincoln agencies, through contact Jim Golden Atlanta, Georgia, furnished all automobiles used in this movement. The Tampa Chamber of Commerce furnished the bus used by the press, and all other vehicles were furnished by the local police units or McDill Air Force Base.

PROTECTIVE RESEARCH

Mr. Cecil Taylor, Protective Research Section, was notified of this movement on November 9, 1963. He advised that two subjects were in the Tampa area. They were: Wayne I. Gainey, 00-2-33,815. Gainey was interviewed by Jacksonville agents and reminded in the custody of his parents during this movement. The other was John W. Warrington, 00-2-33-902. This subject was in jail in Tampa, Florida, for threatening the mayor of Tampa.

COMMUNICATIONS

Communications were conducted by William A. Elder, White House Communications Agency. The “Charlie” net radio communications was used, and a base station was maintained at McDill Air Force Base. Press filing locations were maintained in the Al Lopez Stadium, Ft. Homer Hesterly Armory, and McDill Air Force Base. A public telephone was used by this Service and a White House line was eventually connected.

Telephones were installed at all locations that the President visited.

PRESS AND PHOTOGRAPHERS

The movements of the White House Press corps were supervised by Press Secretary Pierre Salinger and Assistant Press Secretary Malcomb Kilduff.

[ page 4 ]

The President’s entire visit to Tampa was telecast locally on a pool basis. Press and photographers were in controlled areas on all movements of the President.

CONCLUSION

The following persons participated in this survey:

Lt. Col. Ruffin W. Grey, Strike Command, McDill Air Force Base
Chief J.P. Mullins, Chief, Tampa Police Department
Lt. S. L. Clements, Florida Highway Patrol
Sheriff Ed Blackburn, County Sheriff, Hilllsbourough County, Florida
Jack Dempsey, Hillsbourough County Sheriff, Hillsbourogh County, Florida
Jack Dempsy, Hillsbourough County Sheriff’s Office
Capt. Robert A. Moon, 836th Air Patrol Division
Capt. William T. Saxton, Strike Security Division
Jack C. Overstreet, CSI McDill Air Force Base
Capt. Jim Diamond, Tampa Police Dept.
Capt. T. J. Buchanan, Tampa Police Department
Capt. E. F. Bowen, Jr., Tampa Police Department
Archie Adair, Hillsbourough County Sheriff’s Office

Following are the personnel who participated in the security measures:

Tampa Uniform Police……………………………… ..   162
Tampa Motorcycle Escort………………………………   30
Tampa Detectives………………………………………    35
Florida State Patrol……………………………………..    15
Hillsbourough County Sheriff’s Office…………………   11
St. Petersburg Uniformed Police    ……………………..   20
Clearwater, Fla. Uniformed Police……………………..    30
CSI………………………………………………………   12
Military Police ………………………………………       100
Airmen, McDill Air Force Base ………………………    200
Constable’s Ofice, Tampa…………………………….         5
Tampa Fire Department……………………………….       25
White Houe Detail Agents ……………………………       17
Jacksonville Agents ……………………………………       2
Tampa Agents …………………………………………..      1
                                                                             TOTAL   665

[page 5]

The following are attached to this report:

Guest List – Speaker’s Platform, Al Lopez Stadium
Guest List – Speaker’s Platform, Ft. Homer Hesterly Army

Very truly yours,

Gerald S. Blaine
Special Agent

APPROVED:

Signature
Gerald A. Behn
Special Agent in charge

Attachments (6)

2        ccs Tampa
2          ccs Jacksonville

GSS:caw 

Sunday, January 6, 2013

JFKToday2013 Calendar

JFKToday2013



JFK TODAY – 2013

COPA Calendar

January 1 - 2013 - the 50th Year Since JFK Was Assassinated Begins. 

January – 21 Monday - Martin Luther King Day in 2013

February - 21- 1965 Malcolm X assassinated in Manhattan’s Audubon Ballroom 

February 25 - lawyers for the Justice Department will be defending the JFK assassination cover-up in open court in Washington DC .http://jfkfacts.org/assassination/news/justice-dept-official-denies-joannides-received-medal-for-jfk-cover-up-cia-declines-to-provide-proof/

March – 10 – 16 Sunshine Week – Your right to know.
March – 16 – James Madison birthday.

March – 25 – Jack Ruby’s birthday.

April – 4. 1968 – MLK assassinated in MemphisTennessee.
April 14, 1865 – Lincoln Assassinated.

May 29, 1917 – JFK’s birthday.

June – 5, 1968 – RFK assassinated in Los AngelesCalifornia.

June – 10 1963 – 12 PM - JFK gives “Peace Speech” at American University. Annual COPA memorial observance at JFK Monument at AU.

July 4, 1966 – LBJ signs the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), which went into effect the following year.

August 2, 1923 – President Warren Harding died suspiciously while traveling.
August 20, 1940 – Leon Trotsky assassinated in Mexico
August 21, 1983 -The assassination of  former Philippine Senator, Benigno Aguino.
August 22, 1962 – French President Charles De Gaulle of France survives one of several assassination attempts against him 

September 1998 – The Final Report of the Assassinations Records Review Board is Released  http://www.fas.org/sgp/advisory/arrb98/index.html

September 14, 1901 – President William McKinley assassinated in BuffaloNY
September 21, 1976 – Orlando Letelier of Chile assassinated in Washington DC

October 17-19 - October  Conference – “Passing the Torch” Cyril H. Wecht Institute of Forensic Science and Law Duquesne University Ben Wecht Program Administrator 319 Fisher Hall 600 Forbes Ave. Pittsburgh, PA  15282 P: 412-396-1049 F: 412-396-1331 www.duq.edu/forensics

October 26. 1992 – The JFK Act becomes law.

November 5, 1990 – Rabi Meir Kahane assassinated in New York City.

November 22 – DallasTexas COPA

December 14-15-16 – James Douglas and RFK aide Paul Schrade host a JFK, the Unspeakable & 2013 at Rowe Camp & Conference Center 22 Kings Highway, Rowe, MA 01367 Phone: (413) 339-4954
Email: info [at] rowecenter.org http://www.rowecenter.org/events.php?event=139

2017 Project – 2017 is when the JFK Act of 1992 requires all of the remaining government records related to the assassination of President Kennedy to be released to the public, unless specifically withheld by the President. The National Archivist is to certify to the President that all of the JFK Assassination records are now public. We will be organizing a series of events around this date in order to try to generate the remaining records be released before then.


Thursday, January 3, 2013

Highlights from "The Kennedy Detail"


Blaine & McCubin

The Kennedy Detail – JFK’s Secret Service Agents Break Their Silence by Gerald Blaine, with Lisa McCubbin (Gallery Books, Simon & Schuster 2010)

Since Agent Blaine was the chief advance man for the Tampa trip, there is a lot of information about it in his book, with special emphasis on the threats and the need for agents on the back of the president’s car.

Blaine worked closely with Tampa police chief Mullens, who is quoted in the news report about the third threat against the president that Blaine doesn’t mention.

From “The Kennedy Detail”: 

p.xiii – “My initial goal in writing the story of the Kennedy Detail was to set history straight, to leave a book for my grandchildren that they could read and know was the truth beyond any measure of doubt…”

p. xv “Clint Hill (Foreward) It has been nearly fifty years since President Kennedy was assassinated before my eyes but the memories of that dreadful day in Dallas are as clear and painful as if it happened only yesterday.”

“Atoka” – “the Kennedys’ quiet retreat in Middleburg, Virginia

p. 16 Jerry Behn, the Special Agent in Charge of the White House Detail

p. 17. “…Even though President Kennedy spent most winter weekends at the “southern White House” in Palm Beach, he hadn’t made a public appearance in the state of Florida since he and Mrs. Kennedy greeted the returning “Bay of Pigs” prisoners the previous December. The Secret Service had identified numerous threats from Cuban sources, mostly in Florida, as a result of Kennedy’s botched invasion of Cuba almost three years earlier. Surely Jerry Behn had briefed the president on the risks of a public appearance in Florida.”

p. 23 Carlyle Hotel – New York City (p.28) “The burgers at the Carlyle’s Bemelmans Bar were as famous as the fanciful meals murals that decorated the walls of the renowned New York landmark, and at this point Blaine was so hungry, he could taste one.” (p. 366) “There was a small café off the lobby of the (Carlyle) hotel and Clint would sometimes stop in there before he headed to his room, to sit at the bar with a scotch. He’d try to focus on the plans for the days ahead, but as he stared into the glass, sitting all alone, the visions would inevitably creep into his thoughts. When Tommy Rowles, the Irish bartender, first started noticing Hill come into the bar, he tried to make conversation. He recognized the man – had seen him on occasion with Mrs. Kennedy. But it quickly became clear that the man who came in alone, and left alone, wasn’t interested in conversation. The empty look in the man’s eyes (after the assassination) nearly broke Tommy’s heart.”

p. 24 “Suddenly a loud screech sounded from the walkie-talkie in the pocket of his trench coat. He pulled it out and held it up to his ear. The handheld radio was tied directly to the Air Force One frequency. Roy Kellerman’s voice came through the receiver.‘Dangle, do you read me?’ Code name were always used over the radio. The senior Secret Service agents all had code names that began with the letter D, and Godfrey’s was Dangle.”

p. 25 “Sandy Garelick was a senior police officer who headed up the New York City Bureau of Special Services and Investigations (BOSSI) squad and was the point man for setting up additional security for the president’s visits to that city. He had handpicked his squad and the team was great to work with. Professionally they were among the best in the country. Garelick, however, had a strong personality that could present a real challenge for the Secret Service advance agents. Garelick didn’t seem to realize that the borders of the Untied States extended beyond New York City, and he wanted to know what the president would be doing every minute he was in BOSSI territory. Garelick thrived on attention the publicized presidential visits brought to his unit and proudly utilized the thirty thousand New York Police Department officers to ensure the president’s security. The conflicts came during the off-the-record visits like this one when President Kennedy wanted to slip into the city as quietly as possible, with no fanfare. There had been enough clashes in the past three years that you could almost see President Kennedy cringe the minute he saw Sandy Garelick.”

p. 44 “Arrangements had been made for the agents’ extended stay in West Palm Beach at a motel called Woody’s, not far from Ambassador Joseph Kennedy’s estate. Woody’s Motel looked like it had been around for decades and was in need of some updating, but it advertised air-conditioned rooms and fit the Secret Service per diem allowance for lodging.

p. 45 “The house ws located on North Ocean Boulevard the main road that paralleled the beach. Monterey Road intersected with North Ocean Boulevard directly in front of the Kennedy’s walled-in property…The biggest problem was that the back of the house was completely exposed to the ocean…(attended) St. Edward Chruch,…a short distance from the family’s oceanfront home.”

p. 52 “Meanwhile, the name of a seventy-three-year-old man from New Hampshire had reappeared as a threat in the Secret Service Protective Research Section (PRR). He’d been in the files for years for writing threatening notes to previous presidents. A nationwide Teletype alert was sent out with details of the man’s description and his ramshackle Buick sedan. Four days later,…Pavlick was arrested when the Palm Beach police spotted his car, not far from the Kennedy compound…he decided he’d kill the president-elect when he came out of church…Richard Pavlick fit the typical threat profile case.”

p.54 “….Paul Young’s Restaurant, on Connecticut Avenue, where Jack Kennedy’s father, Ambassador Joseph Kennedy, was hosting a black-tie private party for the entertainers and celebrities who had attended or performed at the pre-inauguration gala that night…Jackie Kennedy left the party around two, but President-elect Kennedy stayed until four in the morning.”

p. 57 “The president was taken by helicopter directly from Andrews to the family’s new retreat in Atoka, Virginia, near Middleburg, where Mrs. Kennedy and the children were spending the weekend. Mrs. Kennedy had designed the house, which sat on a large piece of property on Rattlesnake Mountain overlooking the Blue Ridge Mountains, and it had only been completed in October (1963). Mrs. Kennedy had dubbed the place “Wexford” after the county in Ireland where the Kennedys were from, but the Secret Service just called it ‘Atoka.’”  

p.58 “…Before he left for Tampa on Monday, he had to check for updated threat suspects at the Protective Research Section…Agent Blaine loved doing advances. To him it was the most exciting and challenging part of being on the White House Detail. He’d much rather be coordinating security in a new city or foreign country than standing post on a dark night in Hyannis Port or Palm Beach, looking out at the ocean.”

“In reality, the advance work was 95 percent of the effort in guaranteeing the president’s safety on a trip. The political team put together the president’s itinerary and it was the Secret Service’s job to figure out how to move the president safely from one place to the next, how to secure every venue and every route. You had to think like an assassin.”

“The first stop before any advance was always the PRS. Located in the Executive Office Building, next door to the White House, the PRS offices were the nerve center for tracking threat cases. Any time there was a threat made against the president’s life – whether it was a written letter, a phone call, details gathered from an informant, field investigation, or an unstable person trying to get inside the Northwest Gate of the White House – an investigative report was initiated and a case file number issued. A PRS agent would type the report on carbon paper so there would be multiple copies, noting the threat maker’s name, last known address, a synopsis of the threats made, a description of the person, and their medical history, if known.”

“Categories were analyzed and categorized according to the seriousness of the threat. They ranged from ‘extremely dangerous’ to the innocuous ‘gate crasher.” There were always people who would show up at the Northwest Gate demanding to see the president about one thing or another…”

“Whenever someone made a threat against the President , they would be categorized as a permanent risk. There’d be an evaluation, the individual would be monitored, and the case file would remain in the Protective Research file for as long as the person was still alive….”

“The records room of the PRS office contained rows and rows of gray metal four-drawer file cabinets that held thousands of threat suspect files, organized by case number. There were smaller file cabinets where index cards of each suspect were organized both geographically and alphabetically. The cards were cross-referenced to the case file. Thus if you knew either the name of a suspect or their last known location, you could go to the small index drawers, locate the card, which would have the case number on it, then go to the large filing cabinets to get the master file.”

“The most serious threat suspects were the ones on the flash cards every agent carried with them at all times. It was the nature of threat makers to wander as vagabonds or itinerants, moving from town to town or state to state. You never knew when or where one of them might show up”

“Agent Blaine had called the PRS from New York City earlier that morning and requested any Florida files be pulled. When Blaine entered the records room, Cecil Taylor, the Special Agent on duty, had some index cares and manila file folders laid out on the table for him.”

[There were two active cases]

Blaine picked up one of the files. The subject was a man named Wayne Gainey. The picture showed a nice-looking, clean-shaven young man with a crew cut. He could have been a bagger worker at the supermarket, or an elementary school teacher. Threat suspects could be men or women, young or old, peaceful or sinister. They could be your neighbor next door and you’d never know it. Blaine flipped the card over read the profile…”

“Subject made a statement of a plan to assassinate the President in October 1963. Subject stated he will use a gun, and if he can’t get close he will find another way. White Male – Age 20 – 5’9”- 155 Lbs., - Hazel Eyes – Brown Hair Light complexion – slender build.”
Blaine sat down in the chair and began reading the file. The investigating field agent in Tampa, Arnie Peppers, had been conducting regular follow-up visits with the young man’s parents and the attending psychiatrist. Blaine knew Arnie Peppers well; his investigations were always thorough.”

“…The second file was much thicker. John William Warrington. White male, age fifty-three, five feet, nine and half inches, medium build; blue eyes, thin, graying hair; slightly stooped. The man had a long history of letter writing and making verbal threats. The most recent entry in the file showed that Warrington had written a number of threatening letters addressed to President Kennedy postmarked October 15, 16 and 17 in Tampa. He’d also sent an extortion letter to a local bank president, which had gotten him arrested on October 18 in Tampa. He was currently being held in the Tampa city jail.”

They also considered (p. 61) a threat from Chicago, Thomas Arthur Valle.

(p. 63) “There weren’t ANY active threats in Texas.”

Top Ten Threats:

1)      Stanley Berman – professional gate crasher.
2)      Carl Brookman – on record with FBI subversive activities with Nazi Party and possible association with the Communist Party. Possesses firearms.
3)      William Robert Bennett – disabled veteran
4)      John Francis Donovan – letter and telegram writer. Considered a nuisance.
5)      Johnnie Mae Hackworth – letter writer, religious fanatic who made threats against the president, arrested in 1955 and 1960.
6)      Josef Molt Mroz – picketer and “Polish Freedom Fighter”
7)      Barney Grant Powell – threatened Truman, extreme temper, violent man with assault background, carries firearms.
8)      Peppie Duran Flores – threatened Vice President Lyndon Johnson. Says he is a communist and pro-Castro.
9)      Wayne L. Gainey – claimed the KKK authorized him to kill the president in 1963. Teenager.
10)  John William Warrington – mental; wrote five letters threatening JFK for his association with Martin Luther King, Jr.; says he will be lying in ambush in Florida.

(p.73-74) “…Bert DeFreese was the agent conducting the advance for the Miami stop….” DeFreese notifies Blaine of the Joseph Milteer report.

(p. 80) “SS100X cost the Ford Motor Company two hundred thousand dollars to build, but the Secret Service didn’t have that kind of money in the budget. So Ford leased the car to the Secret Service for five hundred dollars a year…”

(p. 83) Re: Trip to Naples, Italy. “….but finally he leaned over to President Kennedy and said, ‘Shall we tell them to get off the back of the car?’”

“President Kenendy said simply, ‘No, I want them there.”

(p. 85) “After checking into the Sheraton Dallas the night before, Win Lawson had taken a walk around the downtown area. There had been some disturbing incidents in Dallas recently, and Lawson wanted to get a feel for the city’s attitude. Just three weeks earlier, United Nations ambassador Adlai Stevenson was heckled as he gave a speech at the Adolphus Hotel on UN Day, and then was assaulted and spat on as he walked from the Dallas Memorial Auditorium to his waiting limousine….”

(p.100) “Win knew the scenario was unlikely in Dallas, but even still, as he looked up again at all the open windows, he was concerned about the exposure. Fortunately they’d have SSI00X in Dallas, which had the rear steps and handholds so agents could be perched directly behind the president and could react quickly. He’s be sure to tell Roy Kellerman, the Special Agent in Charge for the Texas trip, that when the motorcade was driving through downtown, agents would need to be on the back of the car.”

(p.110) “Gordon Parks from the White House Communications Agency accompanied the agents on the trip, and his first task was to set up a radio connection to the White House in one of the hotel rooms. The agents tried to use the radio to call home, but the connection was so bad and so little was interpreted during the conversations that is seemed a worthless exercise…”

(p.123) Andy Berger connects with Sinatra.
(129) “…Jackie decided she wanted to be at Hammersmith Farm, the forty-eight-acre estate in Newport, Rhode Island, that belonged to her stepfather, Hugh Auchincloss. Jackie had spent childhood summers at the twenty-eight-room Victorian mansion that overlooked Narragansett Bay, which had also been the site of her and Jack’s wedding reception…The weekend of September 21, 1963, the president, Mrs. Kennedy, and their children were joined at Hammersmith by some of their closest friends, Paul “Red” Fay and his wife Anita…”

(p. 130-131) “One of the White House photographers, Robert Knudsen,...” makes film about the president’s murder.

(p. 139)  “The Secret Service in Florida spent much of their time following up on plenty of similar leads that turned out to be unfounded. There had been a myriad of alleged Cuban plots to assassinate the president, but thus far not one case had turned out to be a real threat. In one instance, the Secret Service intercepted an interesting letter, postmarked Havana, that was sent to a Cuban immigrant named Bernardo Morlaes in Miami. The letter refereed to a plan to kill President Kennedy, but the investigation found that Morales – the recipient – was again an anti-Castro supporter who was being framed by the other side, in an effort to get Morales thrown in jail. Nine times out of ten, the leads turned out to be hoaxes, but the Secret Service couldn’t take any chances. They investigated everything that came to their attention.”

 “…The whole idea of having the Secret Service agents close to the president was for them to be able to shield him with their own bodies. The further away they were from him, the longer it took to react.”

(p. 162) “….Bert just told me about the order not to have the agents on the back of the bubble top…’That’s right. The order came from the Boss himself. He wanted the agents off the back of the car in order for the people to get an unobstructed view. He doesn’t want to appear like he’s not accessible.”

(p.164) – Hotel Texas, Fort Worth – won’t accept black SS agent (Bob Faison)

(p.174) “Aboard the press plane, cocktails were being consumed at a fast and furious rate. There was no food aboard, but drinks were plentiful, and the atmosphere turned into a party. The Secret Service agents still had responsibilities once they landed in Fort Worth, so for them, Cokes and coffee were the drinks of choice. They weren’t allowed to drink while on duty and none of them would ever risk losing their jobs for the small pleasure of a beer, even after such a grueling day. Winding down for them would have to wait.”

(p. 176) “…While standing in the lobby with some of the other agents, a couple of reporters reminded them of the invitation to the press club….But for the other eight agents who’d been on duty all day without a meal, the idea of a free buffet was something they couldn’t pass up Unfortunately, by the time Dave Grant, Clint Hill, Andy Berger, Dick Johnsen, Paul Landis, Ernie Olson, Don Lawson, Jack Ready, and PDS agent Glen Bennett got to the club, all the food was gone. Nothing else was open at this time of night. ‘Sorry about that,’ Merriman Smith said…It was better than nothing. A beer or a scotch and soda would at least wash down the peanuts and hopefully help them relax enough so that sleep would come easily. Every Kennedy Detail agent knew there was absolutely no drinking while on duty, but there were no off-duty alcohol policies that were emphasized by management. The agents’ characters and ability to perform were constantly being monitored and none of them would take the risk of overindulging in alcohol. Like anybody with a stressful job, a beer or two at the end of a long day was simply a way to unwind. On the White House Detail the reality was that there was no start or stop time for the agents. The agents stuck to themselves and shared a few laughs about the days hectic events while Dave filled them in on what to expect the next day in Dallas. Everybody had a beer or two, or a mixed drink, but with no food around, they decided to leave. A few of the White House press corps had heard about an after-hours place a few blocks away called the Cellar, which was a beatnik type of coffee shop where scantily clad waitresses doubled as singers. The Cellar didn’t serve alcohol, but perhaps they could get a sandwich….Unfortunately, the Cellar didn’t have much in the way of food either, so after a couple glasses of fruit juice, the group returned to the hotel. Paul Landis had struck up a conversation with an attractive female reporter and a Fort Worth police officer, and wound up not leaving until about 5:00 AM. By the time the warm feeling he’d had from the scotch and soda several hours earlier had worn off, when he got to his room, he fell dead asleep.”

(p.185) “Here in downtown Fort Worth, office buildings from six to ten stories high surrounded the open parking lot….But behind any one of the open windows across the street a demented individual could be sighting a rifle as he wrestled with the demons inside his head: Should he or shouldn’t he? Was it the right time? What if he missed? And what if he hit him dead-on? Think of the fame he’d achieve by shooting that goddamned Negro-loving commie president. It was no secret there were plenty of people in Texas who hated everything President Kennedy stood for.”

(p.195) “Lawson made one final call to the Protective Research Section to make sure no new threats had come in overnight. PRS hadn’t received any new names; there were just the regulars, the ones the agents all carried on index cards in their jacket pockets…”

(p.212) “The triangular canyon of buildings created an echo chamber that masqueraded the sound such that even many of the Secret Service agents, all of whom were expert marksmen with high powered rifles, didn’t recognize it as gunfire…”

(p.217) “Clint lunged,…A pool of blood covered the floor. And slumped across the seat, President Kennedy lay unmoving, a bloody, gaping, fist-sized hole clearly visible in the back of his head…”

(p.230) “ken O’Donnell agreed with Secret Service agents’ recommendations that Johnson should return to Washington as soon as possible and yes, he should leave Dallas on Air Force One. Woody Taylor was told to call the Dallas White House switchboard and have them notify Colonel Swindal, the commander of the aircraft, to be prepared to take the president back to Washington, D.C. as soon as possible…”

(p. 231) (Secret Service Chief James “Jim”) “…Rowley was attending a graduation luncheon for Secret Service school attendees at O’Donnell’s Sea Grill restaurant…”

(p. 233) Parkland Hospital 12:39 “…A representative from the CIA appeared a while later….” (Andy Berger)

(p. 254) “Art Godfrey’s midnight shift agents in Austin were headed back to Washington, D.C., on a Strategic Air Command KC135 that had departed Bergstrom Air Force Base at 3:00 PM….The military had all their units on radio silence because of a Strategic Air Command order….”

(p. 255) “Agents Win Lawson and Dave Grant had watched Air Force One take off from Love Field….They’d been instructed to report directly to the Dallas police headquarters to observe the questioning of a suspect who had already been captured. Although seeing Lee Harvey Oswald’s arrogant behavior and hearing his snide remarks to Dallas investigators’ questions triggered their anger, Win and Dave refused to let it influence their judgment about whether Dallas police had the right man. Lee Harvey Oswald certainly did fit the classic profile of an assassin driven by a fanatical desire for recognition, but the seasoned agents knew physical evidence was also needed to prove Oswald’s guilt.”

(p. 257) “Paul Rundle,…was put in charge of securing Johnson’s residence. There would be three perimeters of security. The first, outer layer would be manned by the D.C. metropolitan police, the next perimeter would be manned by the National Guard, and the third and final layer of protection would be the Secret Service agents from the presidential and vice presidential details, supplemented by agents from nearby field offices…Agent Toby Chandler,….was one of the agents assigned to help field incoming phone calls…”

(p. 262) “At 9:25PM the afternoon shift traveled with President Johnson to the Elms at 4040 Fifty-second Street, just five minutes from the White House, where Agent Paul Rundle was waiting to brief them on the new security. ‘Listen,’ Rundle said, ‘There are rumors flying all over the place but the truth is, nobody knows who might have been behind the assassination. They’ve got this guy Oswald in custody in Dallas, and while he could easily be a deranged sociopath, there’s still the chance he was part of a bigger conspiracy. Could be Cuban, Mafia, or some Soviet-backed plan to overthrow the government. It’s just too early to know but the orders we’ve been given are to be excessive in our protective measures.’”

(p. 215) Washington D.C. Nov. 23, 1963 2:15 AM “Standing outside in the pitch-black darkness, Agent Jerry Blaine….was on post at the rear corner of President Johnson’s large two-story French chateau-style house close to the back door,….when he heard the sound of someone approaching from the clockwise direction…Instinctively Blaine picked up the Thompson submachine gun and activated the bolt on top…The next instant there was a face to go with the footsteps. The new President of the United States, Lyndon Baines Johnson, had just rounded the corner, and Blaine had the gun pointed directly at the man’s chest. In the blackness of the night, Johnson’s face went completely white. A split second later, Blaine would have pulled the trigger.”


(p. 274) “In Dallas, Lee Harvey Oswald had been charged with the murder of President Kennedy……..There would be a trial of course, but everybody who’d questioned Oswald had no doubts that he was the assassin. The bigger law enforcement concern now was that with so much public hatred and rage directed towards Oswald, somebody might try to take the law into his own hands and kill him before he could stand trail.”

(p. 282) “The Diplomatic Reception Room, where the function for the visiting dignitaries would be held, was located on the top floor of the State Department, overlooking the Lincoln Memorial and Memorial Bridge. On any other day it was perhaps one of the best views in Washington, but today the only place Jerry Blaine wanted to be was with the procession going from the White House to the Capitol. He couldn’t see it from here. Blaine went through the security details with the State Department security staff and after a few hours had a plan in place. Fifty world leaders in one room. It was perhaps the most important advance Blaine had ever been assigned and while he’d gone through the entire checklist, he realized now that no matter how much planning went into an event you could never plan for the unexpected. He still had to type up the Preliminary Survey Report, so he drove straight to the White House…Blaine typed up the report and dropped it off at SAIC Behn’s office,….”

(p. 285) 8 AM - “Jerry Blaine had written down everything he could remember about the Saturday morning incident with President Johnson at the Elms and had arrived early for the meeting with Secret Service chief James Rowley…Blaine was getting nervous. He was here with every supervising agent, with the exception of Roy Kellerman. What was going on?”

“Chief Rowley had arrived at his office…while Rowley was normally confident in the abilities of his men, the assassination was so fresh, so raw, that he was overseeing every detail himself….’Good morning, gentlemen,’ Rowley said as he sat down at the head of the conference table. ‘We have an extraordinary day ahead, so let’s get right down to it.’ He flipped open a file folder and turned to Floyd. ‘Floyd, do you want to give me a brief recap of President Kennedy requesting the agents drop back to the follow-up car in Tampa?’”

“Blain had relaxed a bit. So this wasn’t regarding the Johnson near incident after all. It was about Tampa. But why was he concerned about Tampa now?”

“Everything was going along fine, but I noticed the president continually glancing back at the agents standing behind him,…and he made an unusual request. He was standing up and he leaned toward me…I of course, was sitting in the front passenger seat, while Bill Greer was driving…So, he leaned toward me and said, ‘Floyd, have the Ivy League charlatans drop back to the follow-up car.’”

“To be honest, I wasn’t exactly sure what he meant by ‘Ivy League charlatans,’ but I sure as hell knew what he meant when he said to have them drop back to the follow-up car. I knew he felt they were hovering a bit too close. And this being a political trip and all, I think he was very conscious of the appearance.”

(p. 312) Dec. 10, 1963. “Eighteen days after the assassination, Dallas SAIC Forrest Sorrels and Secret Service inspector Gerald McCann submitted their report on the agents’ drinking investigation to Chief Jim Rowley…”

(p. 316) “Every agent….was suffering…they all felt an overwhelming sense of failure. Rationally, they could tell themselves that they had no intelligence of Lee Harvey Oswald and his presence in Dallas, and that they had limited control when it came to the president riding in an open-top car, but none of these excuses was acceptable to the former Kennedy Detail agents…”

(p. 317) “President Johnson’s personality and demeanor were totally opposite to John F. Kennedy’s/ His vocabulary was littered with obscenities and his temper was quick and sudden. You  never knew what kind of mood he would be in what might suddenly set him off in a tirade….It didn’t take long for stories about Johnson’s unconventional behavior to circulate among the agents. The day shift reported the president was a fairly good marksman at shooting deer by sighting his telescopic rifle over the hood of the leased tan Lincoln convertible, which caused some of the agents to question his sportsmanship…And then there were the eyebrow raising things they witnessed Johnson doing that Kennedy never would have done, things such as President Johnson relieving himself whenever and wherever he pleased, sometimes even in the presence of female press members…..”


(p. 321) “…the FBI was receiving far more flack than the Secret Service for the assassination, due to the Bureau’s handling of Lee Harvey Oswald. It had come out shortly after the assassination that Oswald had been on the FBI’s watch list because of his defection to Russia, and there was speculation about whether the information they had on him constituted a threat that should have been reported to the Secret Service. In reality, Oswald had never threatened  the president, so there was no legitimate reason for the FBI to pass information to the Secret Service…In the aftermath of the assassination, the FBI had conducted an investigation and had determined that Lee Harvey Oswald was the sole assassin. The problem facing Johnson now was related to the facts that had come out  of the investigation: not only had Oswald defected to Russia, but upon returning to the United States he had been involved with groups favorable to Cuba and Fidel Castro. Journalists were taking on the task of investigation and, like Drew Pearson, were igniting firestorms from all different directions. The case of who had killed the President was nowhere near closed.”

(p.334) “On May 7, 1964, Jerry Blaine was conducting an advance in Athens, Ohio for President Johnson’s appearance at Ohio University when he met a man named Jack Hight, who had worked in President Johnson’s senatorial office at one time and was now working in government relations for International Business Machines Corporation. (IBM). Hight and Blaine had dinner one night and Hight’s enthusiasm about the future of IBM and the opportunities it presented was contagious. The company was best known for its typewriters but had become a leader in the growing mainframe computer industry…Jack Hight had got him thinking. Maybe it was time to consider leaving the Secret Service and pursuing a career in the private sector.”

(p.334-5) “…An agent in the Chicago office by the name of Abraham Bolden, who had just been indicted on charges of soliciting a bribe from a defendant for documents related to a counterfeit case, held a press conference to announce that he was being framed. The reason for his indictment, he claimed, was that he had approached the Warren Commission to provide testimony about derelict behavior of Kennedy Detail agents – which included elaborate sex parties and on-duty drinking at Hyannis Port – that he had witnessed while serving a thirty-day temporary assignment on the White House Detail in the summer of 1961. The insinuation was that the Kennedy Detail agents may have been responsible for the president’s death due to laxness in their duties, and Bolden’s arrest was an attempt to shut him up.”

“The claims were absurd. Certainly, it was strange being charged with conspiracy to sell government documents – a crime for which the Secret Service had a pile of convincing evidence against him – that he was suddenly coming forth with these preposterous accusations. On top of everything else, Bolden, an African-American, was claiming he’d been the subject of racism. He said he had logged a complaint with Chief Jim Rowley following his brief stint in Hyannis Port, which was never followed up on.”

“Most of the White House agents had never heard of Bolden, and those who had worked with him when he served the temporary duty nearly three years earlier remembered him only as an agent whose attitude interfered with group cohesiveness. He was no doubt a good investigative field agent who may just have decided to remain in the field. In any event, he was not transferred permanently to the White House Detail.”

“Bob Faison, who was transferred to the Kennedy Detail in September of 1963 and was the first African-American to be a permanent White House Detail Secret Service agent, found Bolden’s claims to be so ridiculous, he simply ignored them…Bob Faison had never met Bolden, but he couldn’t imagine any of his colleagues conducting themselves in the manner Bolden described.”

“In the end, the Warren Commission rejected Bolden’s accusations against the White House Detail agents. What did seem clear was that Bolden was trying to divert attention from the crimes for which he’d been indicted. For the majority of White House Detail agents, the Bolden issue was but another baseless accusation for which they’d have to bite the bullet and remain silent. It was Secret Service policy for agents not to speak publicly about the inner workings of the agency, and in reality Bolden’s allegations were so ludicrous that none of the Johnson Detail agents gave the issue another thought….”

(p. 356) “In 2005, a book was published that claimed ‘JFK was the target of an assassination plot during his long motorcade in Tampa, Florida, on November 18, 1963 four days before Dallas.’”

“Oh really? Jerry thought. He bought the book to see what this author apparently knew that he hadn’t known as the Secret Service agent who conducted the advance for that very trip. Once again he could not believe that stuff like this was being published. No wonder people believed in conspiracy theories. There was so much crap being put out with absolutely no validity to it, but his one was really doozy. The convoluted theory the author had come up with was beyond the realm of reason. The author claimed that the Secret Service’s Tampa advance reports had been destroyed and that the Tampa plot was somehow connected to another plot by the mafia to assassinate President Kennedy in Chicago during his November 2, 1963, visit. The author claimed that JFK had canceled the Chicago trip at the last minute because the Secret Service had knowledge of a four-man hit team that was planning his assassination in Chicago, Tampa or Dallas.”

Blaine wondered where this theory cropped up, since he had been on all those trips; he had knowledge of every threat, everything that was known at the time. Blaine was incredulous. Where did this guy come up with this crazy idea? And then he read that one of the author’s sources was ‘a Secret Service agent named Abraham Bolden.”


“Abraham Bolden? The name Bolden was vaguely familiar, but he couldn’t place it. And then he remembered: Bolden was the Secret Service agent from the Chicago Field Office who, after being charged with a  felony several months after Kennedy’s assassination, had made all those claims about the Secret Service agents being lax in their duties at Hyannis Port. Blaine had to write a sworn statement and he remembered thinking at the time how absurd Bolden’s claims were. Bolden’s case was appealed all the way to the Supreme Court, but in the end he was convicted and sent to prison for offering to sell documents in a counterfeit case. Bolden – a convicted criminal – was the author’s source of the plot in Tampa, which was based on a case allegedly reported to the Secret Service by the FBI involving an alleged four-man hit team that the Secret Service had allegedly covered up. Bolden continued to claim that he was sent to prison to shut him up. Once again it appeared to Blaine that Bolden was grasping at straws – and using JFK’s assassination to try to get his record cleared.”

“Despite earlier rejection of his allegations, Abraham Bolden was allowed to speak with HSCA investigators when the JFK assassination was reopened. Bolden told them that sometime before November 2, 1963, the FBI sent a Teletype message to the Chicago Secret Service office stating that there would be an attempt on Kennedy’s life in Chicago on November 2 by a four-man hit team using high-powered rifles. The HSCA interviewed Ed Tucker and other agents who were working in the Chicago office at that time, and none of them could recall any such thing. The HSCA could not document that such a case existed and found that Bolden’s story was of ‘questionable authenticity.’”

“It had been a long time, but Blaine was compelled to pull out his files to make sure his memory was serving him correctly. Like any good investigator, he had kept all of his personal reports for all these years. Every time they moved to a new house, with his various jobs, Joyce had asked him why couldn’t he throw all that stuff away, but he’d insisted the boxes of files were important. He found the box from 1963 and started going through it. It was all there. Pages and pages of information that refuted all the claims this guy was making. He was holding in his hands the Tampa advance report that had supposedly been destroyed.”

“Jerry remembered that the only possible threat investigation that occurred in Chicago before President Kennedy’s assassination involved a man called Thomas Arthur Vallee….Jerry remembered when Cecil Taylor in PRS had first told him about Vallee, when he was preparing for the Tampa advance…”
 
(p. 366) “At the end of August, the Democratic National Convention was held in Atlantic City, New Jersey. Attorney General Robert Kennedy had lobbied to be Lyndon Johnson’s vice presidential running mate, but President Johnson was worried that having a Kennedy on the ticket would cost him votes in the South. So instead Johnson chose Hubert Humphrey, a U.S. Senator from Minnesota. Robert Kennedy was slated to speak at the convention, and there was a great deal of concern that he would cause a disruption. When Jackie Kennedy decided that she too would like to make an appearance to thank the party for all the support they’d given her husband, Clint Hill worked with Nancy Tuckerman and Pamela Turnure, who had been Jackie’s press secretary, on the security advance to Atlantic City.”

“As it turned out, former attorney general Kennedy did not upset the proceedings. When he appeared onstage, he received an uninterrupted standing ovation that lasted for nearly twenty-two minutes, and his heartfelt speech about how much his brother President John F. Kenney had depended on and appreciated the support of the Democratic Party was the highlight of the convention. At the end of the speech he urged the party to offer just as much support to the 1964 candidates, President Lyndon B. Johnson and Hubert Humphrey.”

“During the moving speech, the eyes of the audience were often turned away from the stage and to an upper balcony where Jackie Kennedy sat, gracious as usual….”

Document on Destruction of Secret Service Records


Date : 07/09/97
Page : 1

JFK ASSASSINATION SYSTEM
IDENTIFICATION Form

AGENCY INFORMATION

AGENCY : USSS
RECORD NUMBER : 154-10003-10065
RECORD SERIES : FILES OF USS ‘INTELLIGENCE DIVISION
AGENCY FILE NUMBER :

DOCUMENT INFORMAITON

ORIGINATOR : USSS
FROM :
TO :
TITLE : HISTORY OF FILE DESTRUCTION IN THE INTELLIGENCE DIVISION

DATE : 12/16/74
PAGES : 6
SUBJECTS:

DOCUMENT TYPE : PAPER, TEXTUAL DOCUMENT
CLASSIFICATION : UNCLASSIFIED
CURRENT STATUS : OPEN
DATE OF LAST REVIEW : 05/19/97
OPENING CRITERIA :
COMMENTS :

12 – 16 – 74

History of File Destruction in the Intelligence Division

At the time of the assassination of President Kennedy in 1963, no Protective Research Section cases had been destroyed. White House cases were initiated in 1932 with WH-1 and they ran through 1950 to WH-50809. Chief’s Office cases were initiated in 1950 with CO-2-1000, and in November 1963 had reached CO-2-34000. “ (The Assassination of President Kennedy was given CO-2-34030). There were also some CO cases and 5-P cases still existing. These latter two file designators had been used sparingly since 1937 for some PRS cases. It is estimated that in November 1963 there were 35,000 file jackets in existence.

These files were considered either active or inactive. Active files were in file cabinets in PRS. Inactive files were located in three other locations: the Federal Records Center in Alexandria, Virginia; the Truman Library in Independence, Missouri; and the Roosevelt Library in Hyde Park, New York. As subjects of prior record became active after having been in an inactive status, their files were returned to PRS.

In addition to file jackets, the PRS manual index in November 1963 contained approximately 500,000 index cards.

These index cards served as both a file locater and a record of investigations conducted for which there were no file folders, nor even reports, in existence. For example, index cards were made for all persons who telephoned the White House, were referred to PRS, and who were then evaluated as innocuous.

Following the assassination of President Kennedy, PRS was reorganized. One of the first projects was a complete review of the files and the master index in the section. All files which did not contain investigative reports were destroyed as were all index cards relating to that file. (At that time many files contained letters or telegrams only and the subjects had not been investigate). At the same time all files were recalled from the Federal Records Center and were reviewed, using the same criteria. By 1965, when the Intelligence Division moved to 1800 G from the Executive Office Building, the initial review was completed. Approximately 15,000 files were destroyed and the subjects’ names deleted from our index. Other deletions from the master index reduced its size to approximately 250,000 index cards.

In 1966, two special reviews were conducted. All files were recalled from the Truman Library (approximately 8,000) and reviewed. Approximately 1,000 of these files were reactivated and 7,000 destroyed. Also, the Kennedy assassination file was reviewed. This file consisted of some 5,000 subjects whose names had been recorded as a result of the extensive federal investigation of the case. Most of these names had no connection with the assassination and the names were deleted from our indices.

Although our reviews since the assassination in 1963 had enabled us to destroy many cases, during this same period we were establishing many cases as a result of the increased amount of material sent to us by other agencies, mainly the F.B.I. As a result o the Warren Commission criticism of both the Service and the F.B.I. for not exchanging intelligence and for not having a working liaison, most of the material sent to us by the F.B.I was retained and tiles were opened on numerous subjects who fit the profile of “another Oswald.” By 1967, we had added approximately 20,000 files as a result of establishing cases after review of material furnished to us by the F.B.I.

During 1967 we reviewed the entire file again to determine which cases would be transcribed for inclusion in the then new computer system. At that time all cases in which insufficient data had been obtained were either destroyed or referred to the field for completion of the investigation. A review of the master index was also made during this year and the master index was finally purged of all extraneous material, so that only index cards relating to existing file jackets remained.

Since the reorganization of PRS, we attempted to refer for investigation all information which we received if we decided to retain the information permanently in our files. However, in the early days of the Intelligence Division it was not possible to do this. Thus, we established an “innocuous file” (C0-2-39700) in which reports or letters were maintained but no investigation had been conducted by this Service. This file was reviewed annually and cases were destroyed, but it continued to grow until at one point the file consisted of 7,000 case jackets. This file was reviewed and eliminated entirely in 1970 and the number (CO-2-39700) is presently used for aircraft overflights exclusively. Our position since 1970 is that, exclusive of 650.0 information which is filed temporarily and reports from other agencies handled by the Special Intelligence and Foreign Branches, all material is referred for investigation before it is retained permanently.

In 1970 the entire CO-2 file was reviewed. We looked at subjects 60 years of age and older. If they had not shown any interest in our protectees since 1960 we destroyed the file but retained the computer record. We also looked at all cases in which the subject, regardless of age, had shown no interest subsequent to 1950. These cases were destroyed and the computer record retained.

Starting in 1971 we began a review of those cases which had been established as a result of reports received from the F.B.I. All right-wing files which reflected the subject had not been active for the past two years (since 1969) were destroyed and the computer record maintained. All left-wing files in which there had been no activity for the previous five years were destroyed. Computer records for each of the above categories were retained.

In 1972 we again reviewed the CO-2 file, using criteria established in the 1970 review.

In 1974 the criteria for reviewing the reports in the Special Branch were changed. A review of all groups was initiated and those cases in which subjects had not been active within the past two years were destroyed. Those cases in which there were incomplete reports were not only destroyed but were also deleted form the computer record.

As of this date (1997) we estimate approximately 7500 (WH cases) are stored in the FDR Library in Hyde Park. These cases are not part of the computer record.



John Machado – Secret Service Official who ordered the destruction of certain files.

(Doug Horne, IARRB, Vol. V, p. 1455)